Department of Community Health Sciences, Aga Khan University, Karachi, Pakistan.
Department of Population Health, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, London, UK
BMJ Open. 2022 Nov 7;12(11):e061482. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2022-061482.
A dearth of qualitative studies constrains in-depth understanding of health service providers' perspectives and experiences regarding the impact of COVID-19 on their mental health. This study explored the mental health impact and needs of of public sector healthcare workers during COVID-19 who working in secondary-level and tertiary-level healthcare settings of Pakistan.
An exploratory qualitative study.
Twenty-five secondary-level and eight tertiary-level public hospitals of Sindh and Punjab provinces of Pakistan.
In-depth interviews were conducted with 16 health service providers and 40 administrative personnel. Study data were analysed on NVivo V.11 using the conventional content analysis technique.
The study identified three overarching themes: (1) mental health impact of COVID-19 on health service providers that included the fear of acquiring the infection and transmitting it to their family members, fear of social isolation and stigma, anxiety related to the uncertainty of COVID-19, nervousness due to media exaggeration and stress associated with excessive workload; (2) mental health needs of health service providers involved in the COVID-19 crisis and available support from the healthcare system, including the expression of the need for counselling services and safe working conditions, the need for paid rest periods, and the need for appreciation and motivation to work in the pandemic; and (3) suggestions to address mental health needs of healthcare workers, including provision of specialised mental healthcare/services, formal training of health managers on managing mental health needs of health facility staff, and assessment and addressing of these needs of the health workforce.
The study emphasises the need to strengthen health system preparedness for recognising and addressing the needs of healthcare professionals. At the system level, there is a need for a specialised unit to provide mental health services and better communication strategies. At the staff level, continuous motivation and appreciation should be given to healthcare professionals either through monetary incentives or formal acknowledgement of their performance.
由于缺乏定性研究,我们对卫生服务提供者在 COVID-19 疫情期间对其心理健康的影响和经历的理解不够深入。本研究探讨了在 COVID-19 疫情期间,巴基斯坦二级和三级医疗机构公共部门卫生工作者的心理健康影响和需求。
探索性定性研究。
巴基斯坦信德省和旁遮普省的 25 家二级医院和 8 家三级医院。
对 16 名卫生服务提供者和 40 名行政人员进行了深入访谈。使用 NVivo V.11 对研究数据进行了分析,采用常规内容分析技术。
研究确定了三个总体主题:(1) COVID-19 对卫生服务提供者心理健康的影响,包括对感染和传播给家庭成员的恐惧、对社会孤立和污名化的恐惧、对 COVID-19 不确定性的焦虑、对媒体夸大的紧张感以及与工作量过大相关的压力;(2) 参与 COVID-19 危机的卫生服务提供者的心理健康需求以及医疗保健系统提供的支持,包括表达对咨询服务和安全工作条件的需求、带薪休息期的需求、在大流行期间工作的赞赏和激励的需求;(3) 满足卫生工作者心理健康需求的建议,包括提供专门的精神卫生保健/服务、对卫生管理人员进行管理卫生机构工作人员精神卫生需求的正式培训,以及评估和解决卫生工作者的这些需求。
本研究强调需要加强卫生系统的准备工作,以认识和满足卫生专业人员的需求。在系统层面,需要有一个专门的单位来提供精神卫生服务和更好的沟通策略。在员工层面,应通过金钱激励或正式认可其绩效,不断激励和赞赏卫生工作者。