Division of Pediatric Surgery, Federico II University Hospital, Naples, Italy.
Division of Pediatric Urology, Meyer University Hospital, Florence, Italy.
J Pediatr Urol. 2023 Feb;19(1):136.e1-136.e7. doi: 10.1016/j.jpurol.2022.10.024. Epub 2022 Oct 22.
Robot-assisted extravesical ureteral reimplantation (REVUR) is a well established approach for surgical treatment of pediatric vesicoureteral reflux (VUR). However, further evidence is needed to confirm its efficacy even in case of complex anatomy.
This study aimed to further confirm the evidence that REVUR is safe and effective in both simple and complex ureter anatomy.
The charts of all patients with VUR, who received REVUR in 6 different institutions over a 5-year period, were retrospectively reviewed. Patients with both simple and complex ureter anatomy were included. Patient demographics, surgical variables, and post-operative results were assessed. VUR resolution was defined as either being resolved VUR on voiding cystourethrogram (VCUG) or clinically without symptoms during the follow-up.
Fifty-seven patients with median age of 6.9 years (range 4.5-12), receiving REVUR in the study period, were included. Eighteen (31.6%) patients had complex anatomy and included prior failed endoscopic injection (n = 13), complete ureteral duplication (n = 2), periureteral diverticulum (n = 2), ectopic megaureter requiring dismembering (n = 1). The median operative time was 155 min for unilateral and 211.5 min for bilateral repairs. The clinical + radiographic VUR resolution rate was 96.5%. Post-operative complications (Clavien 2) included urinary retention following bilateral repair (n = 5, 8.7%), febrile urinary tract infection (UTI) (n = 6, 10.5%) and gross hematuria (n = 3, 5.2%). Comparative analysis between simple and complex cases showed that REVUR was faster in simple cases in both unilateral [p = 0.002] and bilateral repair [p = 0.001] and post-operative urinary retention was more frequent in simple cases [p = 0.004] and in patients with pre-operative bowel and bladder dysfunction (BBD) [p = 0.001] (Table).
This series confirmed that the robot-assisted technique was feasible even in cases with complex anatomy using some technical refinements, that justified the longer operative times in both unilateral and bilateral cases. An interesting finding of this study was the correlation emerged between BBD and risk of post-operative urinary retention and VUR persistence. Our results also excluded any significant correlation between complex cases and risk of post-operative urinary retention. The main study limitations included the retrospective and nonrandomized design, the small number of cases and the arbitrary definition of complex anatomy.
REVUR was safe and effective for management of VUR in both simple and complex ureter anatomy. Complex REVUR required slightly longer operative times, without significant differences in post-operative mordidity and success rates. Aside from complex anatomy, BBD emerged as the main risk factor associated with surgical failure and post-operative morbidity.
机器人辅助的肾盂输尿管再植术(REVUR)是治疗小儿膀胱输尿管反流(VUR)的一种成熟的手术方法。然而,即使在复杂解剖结构的情况下,也需要更多的证据来证实其疗效。
本研究旨在进一步证实 REVUR 在简单和复杂输尿管解剖结构中均安全有效的证据。
回顾了 6 家不同机构在 5 年内接受 REVUR 的所有 VUR 患者的图表。纳入了具有简单和复杂输尿管解剖结构的患者。评估了患者的人口统计学、手术变量和术后结果。VUR 缓解定义为排尿性膀胱尿道造影(VCUG)上的缓解 VUR 或在随访期间无症状。
共纳入 57 例中位年龄为 6.9 岁(范围 4.5-12)的患者,在此期间接受了 REVUR。18 例(31.6%)患者存在复杂解剖结构,包括先前内镜注射失败(n=13)、完全输尿管重复(n=2)、输尿管周围憩室(n=2)、异位巨输尿管需要分割(n=1)。单侧手术时间中位数为 155 分钟,双侧手术时间中位数为 211.5 分钟。临床+影像学 VUR 缓解率为 96.5%。术后并发症(Clavien 2)包括双侧修复后的尿潴留(n=5,8.7%)、发热性尿路感染(UTI)(n=6,10.5%)和肉眼血尿(n=3,5.2%)。简单病例和复杂病例的比较分析显示,REVUR 在单侧手术中速度更快[单侧手术:p=0.002],双侧手术中速度更快[双侧手术:p=0.001],简单病例中术后尿潴留更常见[单侧手术:p=0.004,双侧手术:p=0.004],术前有肠道和膀胱功能障碍(BBD)的患者更常见[单侧手术:p=0.001,双侧手术:p=0.001](表)。
本系列研究证实,即使在使用一些技术改进的情况下,机器人辅助技术在复杂解剖结构中也是可行的,这解释了单侧和双侧手术时间延长的原因。本研究的一个有趣发现是,BBD 与术后尿潴留和 VUR 持续存在的风险之间存在相关性。我们的结果还排除了复杂病例与术后尿潴留风险之间存在任何显著相关性。主要研究局限性包括回顾性和非随机设计、病例数量少以及复杂解剖结构的任意定义。
REVUR 对于简单和复杂输尿管解剖结构的 VUR 管理是安全有效的。复杂的 REVUR 需要稍长的手术时间,但术后发病率和成功率无显著差异。除了复杂的解剖结构外,BBD 是与手术失败和术后发病率相关的主要危险因素。