Department of Communication Sciences and Disorders, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, Wisconsin.
Waisman Center, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, Wisconsin.
J Neurophysiol. 2022 Dec 1;128(6):1469-1482. doi: 10.1152/jn.00095.2022. Epub 2022 Nov 9.
Although movement variability is often attributed to unwanted noise in the motor system, recent work has demonstrated that variability may be actively controlled. To date, research on regulation of motor variability has relied on relatively simple, laboratory-specific reaching tasks. It is not clear how these results translate to complex, well-practiced tasks. Here, we test how variability is regulated during speech production, a complex, highly overpracticed, and natural motor behavior that relies on auditory and somatosensory feedback. Specifically, in a series of four experiments, we assessed the effects of auditory feedback manipulations that modulate perceived speech variability, shifting every production either toward (inward pushing) or away from (outward pushing) the center of the distribution for each vowel. Participants exposed to the inward-pushing perturbation () increased produced variability while the perturbation was applied as well as after it was removed. Unexpectedly, the outward-pushing perturbation () also increased produced variability during exposure, but variability returned to near-baseline levels when the perturbation was removed. Outward-pushing perturbations failed to reduce participants' produced variability both with larger perturbation magnitude () and after their variability had increased above baseline levels as a result of the inward-pushing perturbation (). Simulations of the applied perturbations using a state-space model of motor behavior suggest that the increases in produced variability in response to the two types of perturbations may arise through distinct mechanisms. Together, these results suggest that motor variability is actively monitored and can be modulated even in complex and well-practiced behaviors such as speech. By implementing a novel auditory feedback perturbation that modulates participants' perceived trial-to-trial variability without affecting their overall mean behavior, we show that variability in the speech motor system can be modulated. By assaying speech production, we expand our current understanding of variability to a well-practiced, complex behavior outside of the limb control system. Our results additionally highlight the need to incorporate the active control of variability in models of speech motor control.
尽管运动变异性通常归因于运动系统中的不想要的噪声,但最近的研究表明,变异性可能是主动控制的。迄今为止,对运动变异性调节的研究依赖于相对简单的、特定于实验室的伸手任务。目前还不清楚这些结果如何转化为复杂的、经过充分练习的任务。在这里,我们测试了在言语产生过程中如何调节变异性,言语产生是一种复杂的、高度经过练习的、自然的运动行为,它依赖于听觉和躯体感觉反馈。具体来说,在一系列四项实验中,我们评估了听觉反馈操纵的效果,这些操纵可以调节感知到的言语变异性,使每个元音的发音分布向中心(向内推动)或远离中心(向外推动)。暴露于向内推动的干扰()的参与者在施加干扰时以及干扰移除后增加了产生的变异性。出乎意料的是,向外推动的干扰()在暴露期间也增加了产生的变异性,但当干扰移除时,变异性恢复到接近基线水平。向外推动的干扰在更大的干扰幅度()下,以及在由于向内推动的干扰导致变异性已经增加到基线水平以上的情况下,都未能降低参与者产生的变异性()。使用运动行为的状态空间模型对施加的干扰进行模拟表明,两种类型的干扰引起的产生变异性的增加可能通过不同的机制产生。总之,这些结果表明,运动变异性是主动监测的,可以在复杂和经过充分练习的行为(如言语)中进行调节。通过实施一种新的听觉反馈干扰,该干扰可以调节参与者感知的逐次试验变异性,而不影响他们的整体平均行为,我们表明语音运动系统的变异性可以进行调节。通过检测言语产生,我们将对变异性的理解扩展到肢体控制系统之外的一种经过充分练习的复杂行为。我们的结果还突出了需要在言语运动控制模型中纳入变异性的主动控制。