Sreenivasan Sanjeev A, Suri Ashish, Raheja Amol, Phuyal Subhash, Singh Manmohan, Mishra Shashwat, Tandon Vivek, Devarajan Leve J, Kalaivani M, Poodipedi Sarat C, Kale Shashank S
Department of Neurosurgery and Gamma Knife, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi, India.
Department of Neuroradiology and Neurointervention Imaging, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi, India.
Neurol India. 2022 Sep-Oct;70(5):2072-2081. doi: 10.4103/0028-3886.359200.
There is dearth of literature on impact of age - pediatric versus adult, Suzuki staging - early versus late, and revascularization type - indirect versus direct on clinical and angiographic outcome in moyamoya disease (MMD). Hence, we intend to comprehensively evaluate factors influencing outcome in MMD following surgical revascularization.
MMD patients operated at our institute from January 2011 to August 2018 were followed for an average 24 months. Primary outcomes were modified Rankin score (mRS) and stroke risk reduction. Secondary outcome was angiographic outcome score (AOS).
A total of 133 patients including 37.6% adults (>18 years; n = 50) underwent 175 revascularizations - 89 direct (DR) and 86 indirect (IR) subgroups. Mean mRS scores improved in pediatric DR (P < 0.001), IR (P < 0.001), adult IR (P = 0.10), and DR (P = 0.25) subgroups. Recurrent stroke rate was similar in pediatric-DR (2.7%) and IR (7.6%, P = 0.61), and adult-DR (0%) and IR (4.1%) subgroups (P = 1.00). AOS scores improved in pediatric DR (P = 0.002) and IR (P = 0.01), and adult-DR (P = 0.02) and IR (P = 0.06) subgroups. Late-stage MMD (Suzuki IV-VI) showed better improvement in mRS scores than early-stage-Suzuki (I-III; P < 0.001). Recurrent stroke rates were similar (P = 0.26) and AOS scores improved significantly in early- and late-stage MMD (P < 0.001).
In pediatrics, clinical and angiographic outcome significantly improved after revascularization procedure, and in adults, angiographic improvement was more evident than clinical recovery. Late-stage Suzuki MMD patients demonstrated significantly better clinical improvement than early stage. The angiographic improvement was equivalent to early stage, irrespective of age and type of revascularization.
关于年龄(儿童与成人)、铃木分期(早期与晚期)以及血运重建类型(间接与直接)对烟雾病(MMD)临床和血管造影结果影响的文献较少。因此,我们打算全面评估手术血运重建后影响MMD预后的因素。
对2011年1月至2018年8月在我院接受手术的MMD患者进行了平均24个月的随访。主要结局指标为改良Rankin量表评分(mRS)和卒中风险降低情况。次要结局指标为血管造影结局评分(AOS)。
共有133例患者,其中37.6%为成人(>18岁;n = 50),共进行了175次血运重建,分为89例直接血运重建(DR)和86例间接血运重建(IR)亚组。儿童DR亚组(P < 0.001)、IR亚组(P < 0.001)、成人IR亚组(P = 0.10)和DR亚组(P = 0.25)的平均mRS评分均有所改善。儿童DR亚组(2.7%)和IR亚组(7.6%,P = 0.61),以及成人DR亚组(0%)和IR亚组(4.1%)的复发性卒中率相似(P = 1.00)。儿童DR亚组(P = 0.002)和IR亚组(P = 0.01),以及成人DR亚组(P = 0.02)和IR亚组(P = 0.06)的AOS评分均有所改善。晚期MMD(铃木IV-VI期)的mRS评分改善情况优于早期铃木分期(I-III期;P < 0.001)。早期和晚期MMD的复发性卒中率相似(P = 0.26),且AOS评分均有显著改善(P < 0.001)。
在儿科患者中,血运重建术后临床和血管造影结果显著改善;在成人患者中,血管造影改善比临床恢复更明显。铃木分期晚期的MMD患者临床改善明显优于早期。无论年龄和血运重建类型如何,血管造影改善情况与早期相当。