Institute of Urban and Industrial Water Management, Technische Universität Dresden, Dresden 01069, Germany E-mail:
Water Sci Technol. 2022 Sep;86(5):1034-1054. doi: 10.2166/wst.2022.263.
Sewer pipelines often leak due to physical, operational, and environmental deterioration factors. Due to the hidden infrastructure of the sewer systems, leakage detection is often costly, challenging, and crucial at the city scale. Various sewer inspection methods (SIMs) have been developed and implemented at this time. This study evaluates the existing SIMs and categorizes them based on their area of impact (AoI) into three classes. Tier-one (T-I) methods, such as deterioration models and hotspot mapping, tend to grasp a broader and reliable understanding of the sewer systems' structural health and pinpoint the network sections that are more prone to leakage. As an intermediate solution, Tier-two (T-II) non-destructive methods, such as aerial thermal imagery (ATI) and electrical resistivity tomography (ERT), inspect the potential pipe clusters regardless of their material and visualize the leaked plume generated from defects and cracks. Tier-three (T-III) methods include in-pipe SIMs, such as visual and multi-sensory inspections, that can provide an in-depth understanding of the pipe and its deterioration stage. In this study, we suggest that a sustainable sewer inspection plan should include at least two SIMs belonging to different tiers to provide a dual investigation of precision and AoI, a balance between cost and time as well as an equilibrium between self-sufficiency and decentralization.
污水管道由于物理、操作和环境恶化等因素经常发生泄漏。由于污水系统的基础设施是隐蔽的,因此泄漏检测通常是昂贵的、具有挑战性的,而且在城市范围内至关重要。此时已经开发并实施了各种污水检查方法(SIM)。本研究评估了现有的 SIM,并根据其影响区域(AoI)将其分为三类。一级(T-I)方法,如劣化模型和热点映射,倾向于更广泛和可靠地了解污水系统的结构健康状况,并指出更易发生泄漏的管网部分。作为一种中间解决方案,二级(T-II)非破坏性方法,如航空热成像(ATI)和电阻率层析成像(ERT),检查潜在的管群,而不管其材料如何,并可视化由缺陷和裂缝产生的泄漏羽流。三级(T-III)方法包括管道内 SIM,如目视和多感官检查,可以更深入地了解管道及其劣化阶段。在本研究中,我们建议可持续的污水检查计划应至少包括两种属于不同层次的 SIM,以便对精度和 AoI 进行双重调查,在成本和时间之间取得平衡,以及在自给自足和分散化之间取得平衡。