Wang Xiaoshuang, Zhang Chi, Karkkainen Tommi, Chang Zheng, Cong Fengyu
IEEE Trans Neural Syst Rehabil Eng. 2023;31:316-325. doi: 10.1109/TNSRE.2022.3222095. Epub 2023 Jan 31.
The application of intracranial electroencephalogram (iEEG) to predict seizures remains challenging. Although channel selection has been utilized in seizure prediction and detection studies, most of them focus on the combination with conventional machine learning methods. Thus, channel selection combined with deep learning methods can be further analyzed in the field of seizure prediction. Given this, in this work, a novel iEEG-based deep learning method of One-Dimensional Convolutional Neural Networks (1D-CNN) combined with channel increment strategy was proposed for the effective seizure prediction. First, we used 4-sec sliding windows without overlap to segment iEEG signals. Then, 4-sec iEEG segments with an increasing number of channels (channel increment strategy, from one channel to all channels) were sequentially fed into the constructed 1D-CNN model. Next, the patient-specific model was trained for classification. Finally, according to the classification results in different channel cases, the channel case with the best classification rate was selected for each patient. Our method was tested on the Freiburg iEEG database, and the system performances were evaluated at two levels (segment- and event-based levels). Two model training strategies (Strategy-1 and Strategy-2) based on the K-fold cross validation (K-CV) were discussed in our work. (1) For the Strategy-1, a basic K-CV, a sensitivity of 90.18%, specificity of 94.81%, and accuracy of 94.42% were achieved at the segment-based level. At the event-based level, an event-based sensitivity of 100%, and false prediction rate (FPR) of 0.12/h were attained. (2) For the Strategy-2, the difference from the Strategy-1 is that a trained model selection step is added during model training. We obtained a sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy of 86.23%, 96.00% and 95.13% respectively at the segment-based level. At the event-based level, we achieved an event-based sensitivity of 98.65% with 0.08/h FPR. Our method also showed a better performance in seizure prediction compared to many previous studies and the random predictor using the same database. This may have reference value for the future clinical application of seizure prediction.
应用颅内脑电图(iEEG)预测癫痫发作仍然具有挑战性。尽管通道选择已被用于癫痫发作预测和检测研究,但其中大多数都集中在与传统机器学习方法的结合上。因此,在癫痫发作预测领域,可以进一步分析通道选择与深度学习方法的结合。鉴于此,在这项工作中,提出了一种基于iEEG的新颖深度学习方法,即结合通道增量策略的一维卷积神经网络(1D-CNN),用于有效的癫痫发作预测。首先,我们使用不重叠的4秒滑动窗口对iEEG信号进行分割。然后,将具有递增通道数(通道增量策略,从一个通道到所有通道)的4秒iEEG片段依次输入到构建的1D-CNN模型中。接下来,针对分类训练患者特定模型。最后,根据不同通道情况下的分类结果,为每个患者选择分类率最佳的通道情况。我们的方法在弗莱堡iEEG数据库上进行了测试,并在两个级别(基于片段和基于事件的级别)评估了系统性能。我们的工作中讨论了基于K折交叉验证(K-CV)的两种模型训练策略(策略-1和策略-2)。(1)对于策略-1,在基于片段的级别上,基本的K-CV实现了90.18%的灵敏度、94.81%的特异性和94.42%的准确率。在基于事件的级别上,基于事件的灵敏度达到100%,误预测率(FPR)为0.12/小时。(2)对于策略-2,与策略-1的不同之处在于在模型训练期间添加了一个训练模型选择步骤。在基于片段的级别上,我们分别获得了86.23%、96.00%和95.13%的灵敏度、特异性和准确率。在基于事件的级别上,我们实现了98.65%的基于事件的灵敏度和0.08/小时的FPR。与许多先前的研究以及使用相同数据库的随机预测器相比,我们的方法在癫痫发作预测方面也表现出更好的性能。这可能对癫痫发作预测的未来临床应用具有参考价值。