Kummer Natalie, Delémont Olivier, Voisard Romain, Weyermann Céline
École des Sciences Criminelles, Université de Lausanne, Suisse, USA.
École des Sciences Criminelles, Université de Lausanne, Suisse, USA.
Sci Justice. 2022 Nov;62(6):740-748. doi: 10.1016/j.scijus.2022.04.005. Epub 2022 Apr 9.
Forensic practice is the concluding practical course of the forensic science bachelor program at the School of Criminal Justice of the University of Lausanne. Learning activities are constructed around five main objectives for the resolution of simulated forensic case problems: 1) select relevant traces and items to be collected at the scene and perceive their potential value in the reconstruction process, 2) apply appropriate detection techniques in sequence to obtain clues of good quality, 3) process traces using Analysis, Comparison, Evaluation and Verification (ACE-V) methodology, 4) produce and summarise information in oral and written forms to help an investigation, and 5) work collaboratively to benefit from the diversity of group members. Simulating and supervising realistic activities is a complex task that became more and more challenging with a continuously increasing number of students over the years (from ca. 30 in 2016 to more than 60 in 2021). Thus, an educational innovation project was launched and aimed at implementing digital technologies to support the teaching staff. A computer-based crime scene simulation tool (allowing students to visualize 360° crime scenes and relevant items) and a communication tool (to simplify and centralise the communication between the students and the teaching staff) were implemented. This article describes the implementation, added value and limitations of these digital technologies in problem-based learning activities. Prior to 2020, the practical course forensic practice was delivered entirely on-site without specific technologies, and entirely on-line in 2020 (due to the sanitary restrictions related to the COVID-19 pandemic). Finally, in 2021, on-line and on-site activities were implemented with success, combining the best of both approaches in a blended teaching mode. An overall increase in the satisfaction of students and teaching staff was observed with the implementation of these tools. Limiting presence on-site allowed students to take a step back from the activities and collected items. This promoted critical thinking, and together with an increase in structured (on-line and on-site) interactions allowed for a positive, continuous learning experience. While the evaluations of these novel technologies were very positive, students still expressed their willingness to perform certain tasks on-site and a preference for face-to-face interactions.
法医实践课程是洛桑大学刑事司法学院法医学士学位课程的最后一门实践课程。学习活动围绕解决模拟法医案件问题的五个主要目标展开:1)选择在现场收集的相关痕迹和物品,并认识到它们在重建过程中的潜在价值;2)依次应用适当的检测技术以获取高质量线索;3)使用分析、比较、评估和验证(ACE-V)方法处理痕迹;4)以口头和书面形式生成并总结信息以协助调查;5)通过合作从团队成员的多样性中受益。模拟和监督实际活动是一项复杂的任务,多年来随着学生人数的不断增加(从2016年约30人增加到2021年的60多人),这项任务变得越来越具有挑战性。因此,启动了一个教育创新项目,旨在应用数字技术来支持教学人员。实施了一个基于计算机的犯罪现场模拟工具(使学生能够可视化360°犯罪现场和相关物品)和一个通信工具(以简化和集中学生与教学人员之间的通信)。本文描述了这些数字技术在基于问题的学习活动中的实施情况、附加价值和局限性。2020年之前,法医实践课程完全在现场进行,没有使用特定技术,而在2020年则完全在线进行(由于与新冠疫情相关的卫生限制)。最后,在2021年,成功实施了在线和现场活动,在混合教学模式中结合了两种方法的优点。随着这些工具的实施,学生和教学人员的满意度总体有所提高。限制现场参与使学生能够从活动和收集的物品中抽身出来。这促进了批判性思维,并且随着结构化(在线和现场)互动的增加,带来了积极、持续的学习体验。虽然对这些新技术的评价非常积极,但学生们仍然表示愿意在现场执行某些任务,并且更喜欢面对面的互动。