Hellmüller Sara
Coop Confl. 2022 Dec;57(4):415-432. doi: 10.1177/00108367211059448. Epub 2021 Dec 29.
Peace research has taken a local turn. Yet, conceptual ambiguities, risks of romanticization, and critiques of co-option of the "local" point to the need to look for novel ways to think about the interactions of actors ranging from the global to the local level. Gearoid Millar proposes a trans-scalar approach to peace based on a "consistency of purpose" and a "parity of esteem" for actors across scales. This article analyzes the concept of trans-scalarity in the peace process in Ituri, a province in the northeastern Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC). Drawing on qualitative data from more than a year of research in the DRC, I argue that while a trans-scalar approach was taken to end violence, it was not applied to transitional justice initiatives. The result was a negative, rather than a positive peace. By showing the high, but still untapped, potential of trans-scalarity, the article makes three contributions. First, it advances the debate on the local turn by adding empirical insights on trans-scalarity and further developing the concept's theoretical foundations. Second, it provides novel empirical insights on the transitional justice process in the DRC. Third, it links scholarship on peacebuilding and transitional justice, which have often remained disconnected.
和平研究已转向地方层面。然而,概念上的模糊性、浪漫化的风险以及对“地方”被收编的批评表明,需要寻找新的方式来思考从全球到地方各级行为体之间的互动。吉罗德·米勒提出了一种基于“目标一致性”和对不同规模行为体“同等尊重”的跨尺度和平方法。本文分析了刚果民主共和国(DRC)东北部省份伊图里和平进程中的跨尺度概念。基于在刚果民主共和国一年多研究的定性数据,我认为虽然采取了跨尺度方法来结束暴力,但它并未应用于过渡司法倡议。结果带来的是消极和平,而非积极和平。通过展示跨尺度的巨大但仍未被挖掘的潜力,本文做出了三点贡献。第一,通过增加关于跨尺度的实证见解并进一步发展该概念的理论基础,推进了关于地方转向的辩论。第二,提供了关于刚果民主共和国过渡司法进程的新实证见解。第三,将建设和平与过渡司法方面的学术研究联系起来,而这两者往往一直相互脱节。