Jin Michael X, Gilotra Kevin, Young Austin, Gould Elaine
Radiology, Stony Brook University Hospital, Stony Brook, USA.
Cureus. 2022 Sep 15;14(9):e29197. doi: 10.7759/cureus.29197. eCollection 2022 Sep.
Background Patient rotation, foreign body overlying anatomy, and anatomy out of field of view can have detrimental impacts on the diagnostic quality of portable chest x-rays (PCXRs), especially as the number of PCXR imaging increases due to the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic. Although preventable, these "quality failures" are common and may lead to interpretative and diagnostic errors for the radiologist. Aims In this study, we present a baseline quality failure rate of PCXR imaging as observed at our institution. We also conduct a focus group highlighting the key issues that lead to the problematic images and discuss potential interventions targeting technologists that can be implemented to address imaging quality failure rate. Materials and methods A total of 500 PCXRs for adult patients admitted to a large university hospital between July 12, 2021, and July 25, 2021, were obtained for evaluation of quality. The PCXRs were evaluated by radiology residents for failures in technical image quality. The images were categorized into various metrics including the degree of rotation and obstruction of anatomical structures. After collecting the data, a focus group involving six managers of the technologist department at our university hospital was conducted to further illuminate the key barriers to quality PCXRs faced at our institution.. Results Out of the 500 PCXRs evaluated, 231 were problematic (46.2%). 43.5% of the problematic films with a repeat PCXR within one week showed that there was a technical problem impacting the ability to detect pathology. Most problematic films also occurred during the night shift (48%). Key issues that lead to poor image quality included improper patient positioning, foreign objects covering anatomy, and variances in technologists' training. Three interventions were proposed to optimize technologist performance that can lower quality failure rates of PCXRs. These include a longitudinal educational curriculum involving didactic sessions, adding nursing support to assist technologists, and adding an extra layer of verification by internal medicine residents before sending the films to the radiologist. The rationale for these interventions is discussed in detail so that a modified version can be implemented in other hospital systems. Conclusion This study illustrates the high baseline error rate in image quality of PCXRs at our institution and demonstrates the need to improve on image quality. Poor image quality negatively impacts the interpretive accuracy of radiologists and therefore leads to wrong diagnoses. Increasing educational resources and support for technologists can lead to higher image quality and radiologist accuracy.
背景 患者体位旋转、异物覆盖解剖结构以及解剖结构超出视野范围,可能会对便携式胸部X光片(PCXR)的诊断质量产生不利影响,尤其是在2019冠状病毒病(COVID-19)大流行导致PCXR成像数量增加的情况下。尽管这些“质量缺陷”是可以预防的,但却很常见,可能会给放射科医生带来解读和诊断错误。目的 在本研究中,我们呈现了在我们机构观察到的PCXR成像的基线质量缺陷率。我们还开展了一个焦点小组讨论,突出导致图像出现问题的关键问题,并讨论针对技术人员的潜在干预措施,这些措施可用于解决成像质量缺陷率问题。材料和方法 总共获取了2021年7月12日至2021年7月25日期间入住一家大型大学医院的成年患者的500张PCXR进行质量评估。放射科住院医师对PCXR的技术图像质量缺陷进行评估。图像根据包括旋转程度和解剖结构遮挡等各种指标进行分类。收集数据后,我们大学医院组织了一个由技术人员部门的六名管理人员参加的焦点小组讨论,以进一步阐明我们机构在高质量PCXR方面面临的关键障碍。结果 在评估的500张PCXR中,有231张存在问题(46.2%)。在一周内进行重复PCXR检查的有问题的胶片中,43.5%显示存在影响病理检测能力的技术问题。大多数有问题的胶片也出现在夜班期间(48%)。导致图像质量差的关键问题包括患者体位不当、异物覆盖解剖结构以及技术人员培训差异。提出了三项优化技术人员表现的干预措施,可以降低PCXR的质量缺陷率。这些措施包括一个包含教学课程的纵向教育计划、增加护理支持以协助技术人员,以及在将胶片发送给放射科医生之前增加内科住院医师的额外核查层。详细讨论了这些干预措施的基本原理,以便在其他医院系统中实施修改后的版本。结论 本研究表明我们机构PCXR图像质量的基线错误率很高,并证明了提高图像质量的必要性。图像质量差会对放射科医生的解读准确性产生负面影响,从而导致错误诊断。增加对技术人员的教育资源和支持可以提高图像质量和放射科医生的准确性。