University Medical Center Groningen, University of Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands.
Department Public Health, Medical Sciences College, University of Campinas, Campinas, Brazil.
Adv Health Sci Educ Theory Pract. 2023 Aug;28(3):871-891. doi: 10.1007/s10459-022-10192-w. Epub 2022 Dec 12.
COVID-19 struck the world and stretched the healthcare system and professionals. Medical students engaged in the pandemic effort, making personal and professional sacrifices. However, the impact of these sacrifices on students` professional development is still unknown. We applied constructivist grounded theory to individual audio diaries (total time = 5h38 min) and interviews (total time = 11h57min) performed with 18 last-year medical students during the first wave of COVID-19 pandemic in Brazil. The perspective of making sacrifices caused initial emotional distress in medical students, followed by a negotiation process revolving around three themes: predisposition to sacrifice, sense of competence, and sense of belonging. This negotiation process led to three response patterns: Pattern A: "No sense of duty"-the sacrifice was perceived as meaningless, and students showed intense anger and a desire to flee; Pattern B: "Sense of duty with hesitation to act"-the sacrifice was acknowledged as legitime, but students felt unprepared to contribute, leading to feelings of frustration and shame; and, Pattern C: "Sense of duty with readiness to act"-the engagement with the sacrifice was perceived as an opportunity to grow as a doctor, leading to fulfillment and proudness. Students ready to engage with the COVID-19 effort experienced identity consonance, reinforcing their professional identities. Students who felt incompetent or found the sacrifice meaningless experienced identity dissonance, which led to emotional suffering and the consideration of abandoning the course. Monitoring students' emotional reactions when facing professional challenges creates opportunities to problematize the role of sacrifice in the medical profession and scaffold professional identity development.
COVID-19 疫情肆虐,使医疗系统和专业人员不堪重负。医学生投身于这场抗疫斗争,做出了个人和职业上的牺牲。然而,这些牺牲对学生专业发展的影响尚不清楚。我们采用建构主义扎根理论,对巴西 COVID-19 大流行第一波期间的 18 名最后一年的医学生进行了个人音频日记(总时长=5 小时 38 分钟)和访谈(总时长=11 小时 57 分钟)。做出牺牲的观点最初给医学生带来了情绪困扰,随后是一个围绕三个主题的谈判过程:牺牲倾向、能力感和归属感。这个谈判过程导致了三种反应模式:模式 A:“无责任感”-牺牲被认为是没有意义的,学生表现出强烈的愤怒和逃离的愿望;模式 B:“有责任感但犹豫行动”-牺牲被认为是合法的,但学生感到准备不足,无法做出贡献,导致感到沮丧和羞耻;模式 C:“有责任感并准备行动”-学生将参与牺牲视为成长为医生的机会,从而感到满足和自豪。准备好参与 COVID-19 工作的学生经历了身份一致性,增强了他们的专业身份。那些感到能力不足或认为牺牲没有意义的学生经历了身份不一致,这导致了情绪痛苦,并考虑放弃学业。监测学生在面对职业挑战时的情绪反应,为探讨牺牲在医学职业中的作用和促进专业身份发展创造了机会。