Department of Radiology, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI.
Department of Radiology, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI.
Curr Probl Diagn Radiol. 2023 May-Jun;52(3):187-191. doi: 10.1067/j.cpradiol.2022.11.002. Epub 2022 Nov 19.
Words can convey subtle cultural stereotypes and perpetuate subconscious gender biases. Wording in job advertisements that appeals to 1 gender and deters others may unintentionally skew the applicant pool and affect the early phase of the recruitment process. "Masculine" tone can lead to decreased interest among women applicants while 'feminine' wording may not affect a man's decision to apply for the job. In this study, we evaluated the presence and extent of subtle gender bias in job advertisements for radiology faculty positions.
All job postings for faculty radiologists were retrieved from the American College of Radiology Career Center website in July 2020. The complete job advertisement was analyzed using Gender Decoder, a publicly available web-based application, to determine number and percentage of female or male coded words and the overall tone of the ad. The job posts were also stratified by subspecialty, leadership positions and academic versus private practice environments.
Of the 623 job postings reviewed, a little over half (52.0%) of job postings were feminine coded, 26.6% had a masculine tone and 21.3% had a neutral tone. Of the leadership (division director) positions, 50.0% (4/8) had a masculine tone, 37.5% had a feminine tone, and 12.5% had a neutral tone. Among various specialties, pediatric radiology had the lowest percentage of job posts with a masculine tone (10.5%) while nuclear medicine had the highest percentage (41.7%). The most commonly used feminine words were: "support," "responsible," "commitment" and the most common masculine words were: "competitive," "leader," "active."
Most of the imaging job advertisements were feminine coded, with masculine tone in overall 26.6% posts and neutral tone in about a fifth. Leadership posts had a higher percentage of masculine tone. Awareness of these biases is important to enable diversity in recruitment and to ensure a diverse applicant pool.
词语可以传达微妙的文化刻板印象,并使潜意识中的性别偏见永久化。在招聘广告中使用吸引一种性别并阻止其他性别的措辞可能会无意中扭曲申请人池,并影响招聘过程的早期阶段。“男性化”的语气可能会降低女性申请人的兴趣,而“女性化”的措辞可能不会影响男性申请工作的决定。在这项研究中,我们评估了放射科教师职位招聘广告中微妙性别偏见的存在和程度。
2020 年 7 月,从美国放射学院职业中心网站上检索到所有放射科医师教职招聘广告。使用 Gender Decoder(一个公开的基于网络的应用程序)分析完整的招聘广告,以确定女性或男性编码词的数量和百分比以及广告的整体语气。还根据专业、领导职位以及学术与私人执业环境对职位进行了分层。
在审查的 623 个职位中,略超过一半(52.0%)的职位是女性编码的,26.6%的职位语气是男性化的,21.3%的职位语气是中性的。在领导职位(部门主任)中,50.0%(4/8)的职位语气是男性化的,37.5%的职位语气是女性化的,12.5%的职位语气是中性的。在各个专业中,儿科放射学的男性化语气职位比例最低(10.5%),而核医学的比例最高(41.7%)。最常用的女性化词语是:“支持”、“负责”、“承诺”,最常用的男性化词语是:“竞争”、“领导”、“积极”。
大多数影像学招聘广告都是女性编码的,总体上有 26.6%的广告是男性化语气,有五分之一左右的广告是中性语气。领导职位的男性化语气比例更高。了解这些偏见很重要,这有助于在招聘中实现多样性,并确保有多样化的申请人池。