Caring Futures Institute, College of Nursing and Health Sciences, Flinders University, Adelaide, SA, Australia.
Cancer and Palliative Care Outcomes Centre, School of Nursing, Queensland University of Technology, Brisbane, QLD, Australia.
Support Care Cancer. 2022 Dec 16;31(1):46. doi: 10.1007/s00520-022-07509-1.
To develop and establish expert consensus on essential elements of optimal dietary and exercise referral practices for cancer survivors.
A four-round modified, Delphi method (face-to-face and electronic). In round 1, initial statements were drafted based on Cancer Australia's Principles of Cancer Survivorship and input from key stakeholders through a cancer preconference workshop. In round 2, the initial statements were distributed to a panel (round 1 participants) to establish consensus by rating the importance of each statement using a five-point Likert scale. Statements that required significant changes in wording were redistributed to panel members in round 3 for voting. Round 4 was for consumers, requiring them to rate their level of agreement of final statements.
In total, 82 stakeholders participated in round 1. Response rates for survey rounds 2 and 3 were 59% (n = 54) and 39% (n = 36). Panel members included nurses (22%), dietitians (19%), exercise professionals (16%), medical practitioners (8%), and consumers (4%). The mean "importance" rating for all essential elements was 4.28 or higher (i.e., fairly important, or very important). Round 4's consumer-only engagement received responses from 58 consumers. Overall, 24 elements reached consensus following some revised wording, including the development of three new statements based on panel feedback.
Our developed essential elements of optimal dietary and exercise referral practices can help provide guidance to medical and nursing health professionals relevant to dietary and exercise referral practices. Future research should conduct an implementation intervention and evaluation of these essential elements to optimise dietary and exercise care in cancer survivors.
制定并建立癌症幸存者最佳饮食和运动推荐实践的基本要素的专家共识。
四轮改良德尔菲法(面对面和电子方式)。在第一轮中,根据澳大利亚癌症协会的癌症生存原则以及癌症预会议研讨会的主要利益相关者的意见,起草了初步声明。在第二轮中,通过使用五点李克特量表对每个声明的重要性进行评分,向小组(第一轮参与者)分发了初步声明以达成共识。需要对措辞进行重大更改的声明在第三轮中重新分发给小组成员进行投票。第四轮是针对消费者的,要求他们对最终声明的同意程度进行评分。
共有 82 位利益相关者参加了第一轮。第二轮和第三轮调查的回复率分别为 59%(n=54)和 39%(n=36)。小组成员包括护士(22%)、营养师(19%)、运动专业人员(16%)、医疗从业者(8%)和消费者(4%)。所有基本要素的平均“重要性”评分为 4.28 或更高(即相当重要或非常重要)。第四轮仅消费者参与,收到了 58 位消费者的回复。总体而言,经过一些修订措辞后,有 24 个要素达成了共识,包括根据小组反馈制定的三个新声明。
我们制定的最佳饮食和运动推荐实践的基本要素可以帮助医疗和护理保健专业人员提供与饮食和运动推荐实践相关的指导。未来的研究应进行实施干预和对这些基本要素的评估,以优化癌症幸存者的饮食和运动护理。