Gatwood Justin, Brookhart Andrea, Kinney Olivia, Hagemann Tracy, Chiu Chi-Yang, Ramachandran Sujith, Gravlee Emily, Hohmeier Kenneth
University of Tennessee Health Science Center, College of Pharmacy, 301 S. Perimeter Park Drive, Nashville, TN 37211, USA.
Kroger Health, 555 Race Street, Cincinnati, OH 45202, USA.
Vaccine. 2023 Jan 16;41(3):778-786. doi: 10.1016/j.vaccine.2022.12.016. Epub 2022 Dec 14.
To determine the combined impact of provider-facing and text message-based, patient nudges on herpes zoster vaccine series completion.
Following a period during which Kroger Health implemented provider facing nudges, select US patients that initiated herpes zoster vaccination were randomized to receive timed text messages when the second dose was due and available as part of a quality improvement exercise. Main comparisons were between patients intervened by provider nudge only and those intervened by both provider and patient nudges. Data were assessed by GEE-basedlogistic and linear regression, controlling for available patient- and store-level characteristics, and geospatial analyses.
During the baseline period, 100,627 adults received at least one HZ vaccine dose and 83.9% completed the series within 6 months over 88.6 days (SD: 26.53) on average. In the intervention period, 120,339 adults were vaccinated at least once and series completion was 88.3% (both provider nudges and text messaging) and 85.3% (not texted) during this observation window (both p < 0.0001). Time between doses was shorter for those who received text messages compared to both the baseline period and those in the intervention period that were not texted (both p < 0.001). Controlling for multiple characteristics, the odds of completion improved in the intervention period compared to baseline (OR: 1.07; 95% CI: 1.033-1.111), but a noticeably higher completion odds was observed amongst patients who received a text message in the intervention period (OR: 1.35; 95% CI: 1.286-1.414). Adjusting for patient and pharmacy factors, those who were texted received their second herpes zoster vaccine dose 8.6 days sooner (95% CI: -9.08 - -8.17, p < 0.0001) compared to those intervened by the provider nudge only.
The combined use of clinical and patient-focused nudges is a simple mechanism by which pharmacies and other health care access points can address the multi-dose vaccine needs of diverse patient populations.
确定面向医护人员的提示以及基于短信的患者提醒对带状疱疹疫苗系列接种完成率的综合影响。
在克罗格健康公司实施面向医护人员的提示措施后的一段时间里,选取开始接种带状疱疹疫苗的美国患者,随机分为两组,一组在第二剂疫苗到期且可接种时接收定时短信,这是质量改进活动的一部分。主要比较仅接受医护人员提示干预的患者与同时接受医护人员和患者提示干预的患者。通过基于广义估计方程(GEE)的逻辑回归和线性回归评估数据,控制可用的患者和商店层面特征以及进行地理空间分析。
在基线期,100,627名成年人至少接种了一剂带状疱疹疫苗,83.9%的人在平均88.6天(标准差:26.53)内的6个月内完成了整个接种系列。在干预期,120,339名成年人至少接种了一次疫苗,在这个观察窗口内,系列接种完成率为88.3%(同时接受医护人员提示和短信提醒)和85.3%(未收到短信提醒)(两者p<0.0001)。与基线期以及干预期未收到短信提醒的患者相比,收到短信提醒的患者两剂疫苗接种间隔时间更短(两者p<0.001)。在控制多种特征后,与基线期相比,干预期的接种完成几率有所提高(比值比:1.07;95%置信区间:[1.033, 1.111]),但在干预期收到短信提醒的患者中观察到明显更高的接种完成几率(比值比:1.35;95%置信区间:[1.286, 1.414])。在调整患者和药房因素后,与仅接受医护人员提示干预的患者相比,收到短信提醒的患者接种第二剂带状疱疹疫苗的时间提前了8.6天(95%置信区间:[-9.08, -8.17],p<0.0001)。
临床提示与以患者为中心的提示相结合是一种简单的机制,通过这种机制,药房和其他医疗服务接入点可以满足不同患者群体的多剂次疫苗需求。