Department of Plastic Surgery, PGIMER, Chandigarh, India.
Department of Plastic Surgery, PGIMER, Chandigarh, India.
J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2023 Feb;77:170-176. doi: 10.1016/j.bjps.2022.10.041. Epub 2022 Oct 19.
Speech abnormalities due to velopharyngeal insufficiency (VPI) significantly affect communication skills, self-esteem, and scholastic performance. It leads to a poor social, emotional, educational, and behavioral development and a poor quality of life overall in cleft lip palate (CLP) patients. Its early diagnosis and severity assessment using video-nasoendoscopy and speech assessment can significantly contribute to management. The present study evaluated VPI in CLP patients using both tools.
A total of 48 patients with repaired cleft palate were subjected to speech and video-nasoendoscopic assessment. Speech assessment measured severity of hypernasality, speech intelligibility, and voice quality. Video-nasoendoscopy evaluated velopharyngeal port closure to grade the severity of VPI. The speech assessment and video-nasoendoscopy findings were analyzed and correlated.
There was a moderately strong statistically significant negative correlation between the grade of VPI and hypernasality (r = -0.542, p = 0.000). There was a stronger statistically significant negative correlation of grade of velopharyngeal port insufficiency with speech intelligibility (r = -0.634, p = 0.000). About 72% of the patients had abnormal voice quality.
This study is the first attempt at diagnosing and grading VPI on a quantitative scoring based on a ratio scale for the motion of soft palate and pharyngeal walls. The strong correlation between endoscopic grading and speech analysis findings warrants further evaluation of nasoendoscopic grading of VPI in more studies.
由于软腭咽闭合不全(VPI)导致的言语异常会严重影响交流能力、自尊心和学业成绩。它会导致 cleft lip palate (CLP) 患者的社会、情感、教育和行为发展不良,整体生活质量较差。通过视频鼻内镜和语音评估对其进行早期诊断和严重程度评估,可以对管理有重要意义。本研究使用这两种工具评估了 CLP 患者的 VPI。
共有 48 例腭裂修补术后患者接受了语音和视频鼻内镜评估。语音评估测量了鼻音过重的严重程度、言语可懂度和语音质量。视频鼻内镜评估了软腭咽口关闭情况,以分级 VPI 的严重程度。分析并关联了语音评估和视频鼻内镜检查结果。
VPI 分级与鼻音过重之间存在中度强统计学显著负相关(r=-0.542,p=0.000)。软腭咽口不充分的分级与言语可懂度之间存在更强的统计学显著负相关(r=-0.634,p=0.000)。约 72%的患者存在异常的语音质量。
这是首次尝试基于软腭和咽壁运动的定量评分来诊断和分级 VPI。内镜分级与语音分析结果之间的强相关性证明,在更多研究中进一步评估 VPI 的鼻内镜分级是合理的。