Nursing Research Unit, Institute of Social Medicine and Epidemiology, University of Lübeck, Germany.
Department Evaluation and Implementation Research in Nursing Science, Institute for Public Health and Nursing Research, University of Bremen, Germany.
Pflege. 2023 Feb;36(1):20-30. doi: 10.1024/1012-5302/a000927. Epub 2023 Jan 5.
Several reviews are available on the effects of specific nursing tasks in oncology care. However, a synthesis across cancer entities and stages is lacking. To synthesise the results of reviews assessing the scope and effectiveness of tasks of nurses specifically qualified in cancer care. We conducted an Umbrella Review based on systematic searches in six databases and a search for grey literature following a priori-defined inclusion criteria. Further steps: standardised data extraction and quality assessment, determination of the degree of overlap, and structured narrative summary on outcome measures of health-related quality of life, symptom burden, utilisation of care services/resources, and patient satisfaction. All reviews were categorised according to the EONS Cancer Nursing Education Framework and the Omaha System Intervention Scheme. After screening 2,657 references, 11 reviews (10 high quality) for a total of 148 studies were included. Specially qualified nurses and advanced practice nurses take on a variety of tasks in the disease process, especially related to education, counselling, and case management. Effects on outcome measures are mixed, with increased indications of reduced symptom burden. Specially qualified nurses with expanded roles have the potential to contribute to improved oncology care. This emphasises the importance of appropriate task profiles and qualification programs. More well-reported studies based on theoretical framework models are needed.
有几篇综述探讨了肿瘤护理中特定护理任务的影响。然而,缺乏针对不同癌症实体和阶段的综合分析。本研究旨在综合评估专门从事癌症护理的护士的工作范围和效果的综述结果。我们根据事先确定的纳入标准,在六个数据库中进行了系统检索,并对灰色文献进行了检索,开展了伞式综述。进一步的步骤包括:标准化数据提取和质量评估、重叠程度的确定,以及对健康相关生活质量、症状负担、护理服务/资源利用和患者满意度等结局指标的结构化叙述性总结。所有综述均根据 EONS 癌症护理教育框架和奥马哈系统干预方案进行分类。经过筛选 2657 篇参考文献,共纳入了 11 篇综述(10 篇高质量)和 148 项研究。专门从事癌症护理的护士和高级实践护士在疾病过程中承担了各种任务,特别是与教育、咨询和病例管理相关的任务。对结局指标的影响不一,有迹象表明症状负担减轻。扩大角色的专门护士有可能有助于改善肿瘤护理。这强调了适当的任务配置文件和资格计划的重要性。需要更多基于理论框架模型的报告良好的研究。