Raj Senthorun
Manchester Law School, Manchester Metropolitan University, Manchester, United Kingdom.
Fem Leg Stud. 2023 Jan 10:1-25. doi: 10.1007/s10691-022-09504-7.
The teaching of critical race, feminist, and queer theory generally, and of LGBT rights specifically, has developed into a discrete, contested, and politicised area of teaching in English law schools and beyond. While there is some academic discussion on the personal and political significance of 'promoting LGBT rights' within law schools, less considered is how 'LGBT rights' are shaped by the emotions of legal academics and how these emotions circumscribe what we imagine LGBT rights can and/or should mean in law and critical legal study. To illustrate this dynamic, this paper uses critical race, feminist, and queer scholarship alongside work in the emerging field of Law and Emotion to articulate the 'emotional grammar' of teaching a Gender, Sexuality and Law unit at an English law school. Turning to autoethnography, I use my emotional experiences as a methodological tool to explore how emotions co-constitute the pedagogical, political, scholarly, and personal registers of LGBT rights as a descriptive, critical, and normative pursuit. In doing so, I use 'emotional grammar' as a novel way to map how emotions structure legal pedagogies invested in pursuing LGBT rights. Emotional grammar illustrates how emotions structure: (1) the articulation of LGBT rights as an object of study in law; (2) the pursuit of law to secure the rights of LGBT people; and (3) the shape of legal critique relating to LGBT rights.
一般而言,批判种族理论、女性主义理论和酷儿理论的教学,尤其是 LGBT 权利的教学,已发展成为英国法学院及其他领域中一个独立、有争议且政治化的教学领域。虽然法学院内部存在一些关于“促进 LGBT 权利”的个人及政治意义的学术讨论,但较少有人考虑“LGBT 权利”是如何受到法律学者情感的塑造,以及这些情感如何限制了我们对于 LGBT 权利在法律和批判性法律研究中能够且/或者应该意味着什么的想象。为了说明这种动态关系,本文运用批判种族理论、女性主义理论和酷儿理论的学术成果,以及法律与情感这一新兴领域的研究,来阐述在一所英国法学院教授“性别、性取向与法律”课程单元的“情感语法”。转向自我民族志,我将自己的情感体验作为一种方法工具,以探究情感如何共同构成作为一种描述性、批判性和规范性追求的 LGBT 权利的教学、政治、学术和个人层面。在此过程中,我将“情感语法”作为一种新颖的方式,来描绘情感如何构建致力于追求 LGBT 权利的法律教学方法。情感语法说明了情感是如何构建的:(1)将 LGBT 权利表述为法律研究的对象;(2)通过法律来保障 LGBT 群体的权利;(3)与 LGBT 权利相关的法律批判的形式。