Qin Wangjun, Yuan Siyu, Zhao Li, Liu Ying, Xu Liyuan, Zhang Yi, Liu Lihong, Fan Bifa
Department of Pharmacy, China-Japan Friendship Hospital, Beijing, People's Republic of China.
Department of Pharmacy, Siping Central Hospital, Siping, Jilin Province, People's Republic of China.
J Multidiscip Healthc. 2023 Jan 10;16:21-29. doi: 10.2147/JMDH.S397039. eCollection 2023.
Pharmacists are key members of the pain management interdisciplinary team in many developed countries. However, the implementation of clinical pharmacy services in pain management is impeded by the imbalance between the pain physicians and clinical pharmacists specializing in pain management in China. The purpose of this study was to elucidate the perceptions, expectations and current experience of Chinese pain physicians regarding clinical pharmacy services.
An anonymous, self-administered questionnaire was designed according to previously published studies with minor modifications and distributed online to 1100 pain physicians selected randomly in hospitals across all 31 provinces of mainland China in 2021. Data were analyzed using descriptive and inferential statistics.
A total of 1071 valid questionnaires were included for analysis. The pain physicians were from all 31 provinces of mainland China and most of them were from tertiary hospitals holding an undergraduate degree. Among listed kinds of clinical pharmacy services, pain physicians were less comfortable with pharmacists treating minor illnesses (p < 0.001). Pain physicians' experiences with clinical pharmacy services were far less than their expectations (p < 0.001), which is in line with the results that most of pain physicians (65.9%) interacted with pharmacists at a frequency of less than once a week. Significant differences in the experiences were found among ages (p < 0.01) and among years of work experience (p < 0.05) of pain physicians. Pain physicians' expectations of pharmacists were positively correlated with their experiences with clinical pharmacy services (p < 0.001).
Pain physicians in China had positive perceptions and high expectations, but relatively low experiences regarding clinical pharmacy services. Expanding clinical pharmacist pain management credentialing and increasing pain physicians' exposure to clinical pharmacy services are favourable to support the interdisciplinary collaboration in pain management in China.
在许多发达国家,药剂师是疼痛管理跨学科团队的关键成员。然而,中国疼痛科医生与专门从事疼痛管理的临床药剂师之间的不平衡阻碍了疼痛管理中临床药学服务的实施。本研究的目的是阐明中国疼痛科医生对临床药学服务的看法、期望和当前经验。
根据先前发表的研究设计了一份匿名的自填式问卷,并稍作修改,于2021年在中国大陆31个省份的医院随机选取1100名疼痛科医生进行在线发放。采用描述性和推断性统计分析数据。
共纳入1071份有效问卷进行分析。这些疼痛科医生来自中国大陆所有31个省份,其中大多数来自三级医院,拥有本科学历。在列出的各类临床药学服务中,疼痛科医生对药剂师治疗小病不太放心(p<0.001)。疼痛科医生对临床药学服务的体验远低于他们的期望(p<0.001),这与大多数疼痛科医生(65.9%)与药剂师的互动频率低于每周一次的结果一致。疼痛科医生的年龄(p<0.01)和工作年限(p<0.05)在体验方面存在显著差异。疼痛科医生对药剂师的期望与他们对临床药学服务的体验呈正相关(p<0.001)。
中国的疼痛科医生对临床药学服务有积极的看法和较高的期望,但相关体验相对较少。扩大临床药剂师疼痛管理资质认证并增加疼痛科医生接触临床药学服务的机会,有利于支持中国疼痛管理中的跨学科合作。