Research for Inclusive STEM Education Center, School of Life Sciences, Arizona State University, Tempe, AZ 85281.
Department of Biology, Florida International University, Miami, FL 33199.
CBE Life Sci Educ. 2023 Mar;22(1):ar11. doi: 10.1187/cbe.22-02-0022.
Undergraduate research is lauded as a high-impact practice owing to the array of benefits that students can reap from participating. One unexplored construct that may affect student intent to persist in research is research anxiety, defined as the sense of worry or apprehension associated with conducting research. In this study, we surveyed 1272 undergraduate researchers across research-intensive, master's-granting, and primarily undergraduate institutions to assess the relationship among student demographics, research anxiety, and intent to pursue a research career. Using structural equation modeling, we identified that women and students with higher grade point averages (GPAs) were more likely to report higher levels of research anxiety compared with men and students with lower GPAs, respectively. Additionally, research anxiety was significantly and negatively related to student intent to pursue a research-related career. We coded students' open-ended responses about what alleviates and exacerbates their anxiety and found that experiencing failure in the context of research and feeling underprepared increased their research anxiety, while a positive lab environment and mentor-mentee relationships decreased their anxiety. This is the first study to examine undergraduate anxiety in the context of research at scale and to establish a relationship between research anxiety and students' intent to persist in scientific research careers.
本科研究因其学生参与所带来的众多益处而被誉为一种具有重大影响的实践。有一个尚未被探索的结构可能会影响学生继续从事研究的意愿,那就是研究焦虑,它是指与进行研究相关的担忧或不安感。在这项研究中,我们调查了 1272 名来自研究密集型、硕士授予型和主要本科院校的本科生,以评估学生人口统计学特征、研究焦虑和从事研究职业意愿之间的关系。使用结构方程建模,我们发现与男性和 GPA 较低的学生相比,女性和 GPA 较高的学生更有可能报告更高水平的研究焦虑。此外,研究焦虑与学生从事与研究相关职业的意愿呈显著负相关。我们对学生关于缓解和加剧他们焦虑的开放性回答进行了编码,发现研究背景下的失败经历和准备不足会增加他们的研究焦虑,而积极的实验室环境和导师-学生关系则会降低他们的焦虑。这是第一项大规模研究本科生在研究背景下焦虑的研究,并确立了研究焦虑与学生从事科学研究职业意愿之间的关系。