Unit Suicide Research & Mental Health Promotion, Department of Social and Preventive Medicine, Center for Public Health, Medical University of Vienna.
Wiener Werkstaette for Suicide Research.
Health Commun. 2024 Apr;39(2):403-416. doi: 10.1080/10410236.2023.2167580. Epub 2023 Jan 19.
There has been a debate about the suitability of different narratives in educative suicide prevention materials. Whereas some suicide prevention experts recommend raising awareness of suicide by highlighting its prevalence, others argue that this approach may normalize suicide and advocate focusing on help resources instead. Unfortunately, empirical evidence regarding this question is lacking. This randomized controlled trial aimed to test the impact of educative news articles that conveyed different narratives of suicide prevention. One article focused on the prevalence of suicide, one article highlighted professional help resources, and one article emphasized on how everyone can help to prevent suicide. We randomized = 334 participants to read either one of these three articles or an article unrelated to suicide. Data on suicidal ideation, stigmatizing attitudes toward suicidal individuals, attitudes toward suicide prevention, and help-seeking intentions were collected with questionnaires, and implicit measures were used to assess participants' mental accessibility of concepts related to suicide and suicide prevention. Participants exposed to the article highlighting the high prevalence of suicide tended to show a higher accessibility of potentially detrimental cognitive concepts related to suicide. In contrast, the accessibility of the concept of "helping" and that "suicide is preventable" was higher in participants' memory when exposed to materials focusing on help. It seems that the impact of educative suicide awareness materials on readers' access to suicide- and suicide-prevention-related concepts in memory varied depending on the narrative featured in the article.
关于教育性自杀预防材料中不同叙述方式的适宜性一直存在争议。一些自杀预防专家建议通过强调自杀的普遍性来提高对自杀的认识,而另一些专家则认为这种方法可能会使自杀正常化,主张关注帮助资源。然而,关于这个问题的实证证据却很缺乏。本随机对照试验旨在测试传达不同自杀预防叙述方式的教育性新闻文章的影响。一篇文章侧重于自杀的普遍性,一篇文章强调专业的帮助资源,还有一篇文章强调每个人都可以帮助预防自杀。我们将 334 名参与者随机分为三组,分别阅读这三篇文章中的一篇或与自杀无关的文章。通过问卷收集关于自杀意念、对自杀个体的污名化态度、对自杀预防的态度和寻求帮助的意愿的数据,并使用内隐测量来评估参与者对与自杀和自杀预防相关概念的心理可及性。接触强调自杀高普遍性文章的参与者倾向于表现出更高的与自杀相关的潜在有害认知概念的可及性。相比之下,当参与者接触到强调帮助的材料时,“帮助”和“自杀是可以预防的”这两个概念在他们的记忆中的可及性更高。似乎教育性自杀意识材料对读者记忆中与自杀和自杀预防相关概念的可及性的影响取决于文章中呈现的叙述方式。