Department of Experimental Pain Research, Mannheim Center Translational Neuroscience (MCTN), Medical Faculty Mannheim, University of Heidelberg, Heidelberg, Germany; Chronic Pain Unit, Department of Anesthesiology, University Hospital Basel, Basel, Switzerland.
Department of Experimental Pain Research, Mannheim Center Translational Neuroscience (MCTN), Medical Faculty Mannheim, University of Heidelberg, Heidelberg, Germany.
J Pain. 2023 Jun;24(6):957-969. doi: 10.1016/j.jpain.2023.01.009. Epub 2023 Jan 18.
Classically, to electrically excite C-nociceptors, rectangular pulses are used with a duration close to the estimated chronaxie of C-fibres (about 2 ms). Recent results using slow depolarizing stimuli suggest longer chronaxies. We therefore set out to optimize C-fiber stimulation based on recordings of single C-nociceptors in-vivo and C-fiber compound-action-potentials (C-CAP) ex-vivo using half-sine shaped stimuli of durations between 1 and 250ms. Single fiber (n = 45) recording in pigs revealed high chronaxie values for C-touch fibers (15.8 ms), polymodal- (14.2 ms) and silent-nociceptors (16.8 ms). Activation thresholds decreased 2 to 3-fold in all fibre classes when increasing the duration of half-sine pulses from 1 to 25 ms (P < .05). C-CAPs strength-duration curves of the pig saphenous nerve (n = 7) showed the highest sensitivity for half-sine durations between 10 and 25 ms. Half-maximum currents for C-CAPS were reduced 3-fold compared to rectangular pulses (P < .01) whereas the opposite was found for A-fiber compound action potentials. Psychophysics in humans (n = 23) revealed that half-sine stimulus durations >10 ms reduced detection thresholds, pain thresholds, and stimulus current amplitudes required to generate a pain rating of 3 on an 11-point Numeric Rating Scale (NRS) as compared to 1 ms rectangular pulses (P < 0.05). Increasing the duration from 1 to 25 ms led to a 4-fold amplitude reduction for pain-thresholds and stimuli caused an axon-reflex flare. Excitability of single polymodal nociceptors in animals paralleled human psychophysics and we conclude optimized half-sine pulses facilitate C-nociceptor activation. PERSPECTIVE: Electrical stimulation with longer lasting half-sine wave pulses preferentially activates C-nociceptors and changes in the strength duration curve may identify nociceptor hyperexcitability in patients with neuropathic pain.
经典的方法是使用持续时间接近 C 纤维估计驰豫时间(约 2ms)的矩形脉冲来电兴奋 C 伤害感受器。最近使用缓慢去极化刺激的结果表明驰豫时间更长。因此,我们着手基于体内单个 C 伤害感受器记录和体外 C 纤维复合动作电位(C-CAP),使用持续时间为 1 至 250ms 的半正弦形刺激来优化 C 纤维刺激。在猪中进行的单纤维(n=45)记录显示 C-touch 纤维(15.8ms)、多模态(14.2ms)和沉默伤害感受器(16.8ms)的高驰豫值。当将半正弦脉冲的持续时间从 1 增加到 25ms 时,所有纤维类型的激活阈值降低了 2 到 3 倍(P<.05)。猪隐静脉(n=7)的 C-CAP 强度-时间曲线显示,半正弦持续时间为 10 至 25ms 时最敏感。与矩形脉冲相比,C-CAP 的半最大电流降低了 3 倍(P<.01),而 A 纤维复合动作电位则相反。人体心理学(n=23)显示,与 1ms 矩形脉冲相比,半正弦刺激持续时间>10ms 可降低检测阈值、疼痛阈值和产生 11 点数字评分量表(NRS)上 3 级疼痛评分所需的刺激电流幅度(P<.05)。从 1 增加到 25ms 会导致疼痛阈值和刺激的幅度降低 4 倍,导致轴突反射性闪烁。动物中单一多模态伤害感受器的兴奋性与人体心理学相平行,我们得出结论,优化的半正弦脉冲有助于 C 伤害感受器的激活。观点:使用持续时间更长的半正弦波脉冲进行电刺激可优先激活 C 伤害感受器,而强度-时间曲线的变化可能会识别出患有神经性疼痛的患者的伤害感受器过度兴奋。