Muhammed Feysal Kemal, Belay Denekew Bitew, Presanis Anne M, Sebu Aboma Temesgen
College of Natural Science, Hawasa University, P.O.Box:05, Hawasa, Ethiopia.
College of Science, Bahir Dar University, Bahir Dar, Ethiopia.
Sci Afr. 2023 Mar;19:e01519. doi: 10.1016/j.sciaf.2022.e01519. Epub 2023 Jan 2.
A Bayesian joint modeling approach to dynamic prediction of HIV progression and mortality allows individualized predictions to be made for HIV patients, based on monitoring of their CD4 counts. This study aims to provide predictions of patient-specific trajectories of HIV disease progression and survival. Longitudinal data on 254 HIV/AIDS patients who received ART between 2009 and 2014, and who had at least one CD4 count observed, were employed in a Bayesian joint model of disease progression. Different forms of association structure that relate the longitudinal CD4 biomarker and time to death were assessed; and predictions were averaged over the different models using Bayesian model averaging. The individual follow-up times ranged from 1 to 120 months, with a median of 22 months and IQR 7-39 months. The estimates of the association structure parameters from two of the three models considered indicated that the HIV mortality hazard at any time point is associated with the rate of change in the underlying value of the CD4 count. Model averaging the dynamic predictions resulted in only one of the hypothesized association structures having non-zero weight in almost all time points for each individual, with the exception of twelve patients, for whom other association structures were preferred at a few time points. The predictions were found to be different when we averaged them over models than when we derived them from the highest posterior weight model alone. The model with highest posterior weight for almost all time points for each individual gave an estimate of the association parameter of -0.02 implying that for a unit increase in the CD4 count, the hazard of HIV mortality decreases by a factor (hazard ratio) of 0.98. Functional status and alcohol intake are important contributing factors that affect the mean square root of CD4 measurements.
一种用于动态预测HIV进展和死亡率的贝叶斯联合建模方法,能够基于对HIV患者CD4细胞计数的监测为其进行个性化预测。本研究旨在提供HIV疾病进展和生存的患者特异性轨迹预测。对2009年至2014年间接受抗逆转录病毒治疗(ART)且至少有一次CD4细胞计数观测值的254名HIV/AIDS患者的纵向数据,采用疾病进展的贝叶斯联合模型进行分析。评估了将纵向CD4生物标志物与死亡时间联系起来的不同形式的关联结构;并使用贝叶斯模型平均法对不同模型的预测结果进行平均。个体随访时间从1个月到120个月不等,中位数为22个月,四分位间距为7 - 39个月。所考虑的三个模型中的两个模型对关联结构参数的估计表明,在任何时间点HIV死亡风险都与CD4细胞计数基础值的变化率相关。对动态预测进行模型平均后,几乎在每个个体的所有时间点上,只有一种假设的关联结构具有非零权重,但有12名患者除外——在少数时间点上他们更倾向于其他关联结构。研究发现,当我们对模型进行平均时得到的预测结果与仅从后验权重最高的模型得出的预测结果不同。对于每个个体几乎所有时间点后验权重最高的模型给出的关联参数估计值为 - 0.02,这意味着CD4细胞计数每增加一个单位,HIV死亡风险降低0.9