Taylor David N, Hawk Cheryl
J Chiropr Educ. 2023 Mar 1;37(1):41-49. doi: 10.7899/JCE-21-47.
The purpose of this study was to assess chiropractic interns' knowledge and adherence to radiographic clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) and compare their clinical decisions to previous surveys of established practitioners in Canada and Australia.
A clinical decision-making survey was administered to 88 interns. The survey contained clinical scenarios and vignettes with inquiries regarding indications for radiographic referral, the likelihood of referral, and the application of CPGs.
Forty-four percent (43.75%) of the interns were aware of CPGs, 38.75% were unsure, and 17.5% were not aware. When asked specific questions about the appropriateness of diagnostic imaging, the interns' responses were similar to those of practitioners in Canada and Australia. When interns evaluated a clinical vignette, there was lower compliance with CPGs.
The interns' clinical decisions regarding the use of diagnostic radiography did not significantly differ from those of practitioners who were surveyed in other related studies. Interns were inconsistent in applying their decision making in clinical cases. Notwithstanding the similarities with practitioners, some deviation from the guidelines indicates the need for further intern education to improve the implementation of CPGs for optimal cost-effective and clinically appropriate care.
本研究旨在评估整脊实习医生对放射影像学临床实践指南(CPGs)的了解和遵循情况,并将他们的临床决策与之前对加拿大和澳大利亚执业医生的调查结果进行比较。
对88名实习医生进行了一项临床决策调查。该调查包含临床病例和小插曲,涉及放射影像学转诊指征、转诊可能性以及CPGs的应用等问题。
44%(43.75%)的实习医生知晓CPGs,38.75%不确定,17.5%不知道。当被问及关于诊断性影像学检查适宜性的具体问题时,实习医生的回答与加拿大和澳大利亚的执业医生相似。当实习医生评估一个临床小插曲时,对CPGs的遵循度较低。
实习医生在使用诊断性放射检查方面的临床决策与其他相关研究中调查的执业医生相比没有显著差异。实习医生在临床病例中应用决策时并不一致。尽管与执业医生有相似之处,但一些偏离指南的情况表明需要对实习医生进行进一步教育,以改善CPGs的实施,实现最佳的成本效益和临床适宜性护理。