Centre Population et Développement, Paris, France
Central European University, Wien, Austria.
BMJ Sex Reprod Health. 2023 Jul;49(3):158-166. doi: 10.1136/bmjsrh-2022-201712. Epub 2023 Jan 24.
This is the first study contrasting the experience of women residing in France and travelling for abortion services inside and outside their country of residence. We compare travel reasons and costs as well as our study participants' opinions of abortion legislation. The article documents legal and procedural barriers related to accessing local and timely abortions and provides policy recommendations to broaden care options.
The study is based on a mixed-methods research design. Quantitative data were descriptively analysed using Stata and drawn from 100 surveys with in-country abortion seekers collected from 3 Parisian hospitals, and 57 surveys with French residents seeking abortion care in the Netherlands (42), Spain (10) and the UK (5). Qualitative data were thematically analysed using ATLAS.ti and drawn from 36 interviews with French residents (23 in-country abortion seekers and 13 cross-border abortion travellers).
Gestational age (GA) limits were the key reason for cross-border travel, while lack of close-by, timely and good quality abortion care was the main driver for in-country abortion travel. Unlike in-country travellers, cross-border abortion seekers faced significant financial costs and burdens related to such travel. Partners, family members and service providers offered important support structures to both cross-border and in-country travellers.
Legal time limits appeared to be the key driver for abortion-related travel of French residents. Having passed or being at risk of exceeding the GA limit caused women to travel outside their country or department of residence for abortion care.
这是第一项对比居住在法国的女性在国内和国外出行寻求堕胎服务经历的研究。我们比较了出行原因和费用,以及研究参与者对堕胎立法的看法。本文记录了与获取当地及时堕胎服务相关的法律和程序障碍,并提出了扩大护理选择的政策建议。
本研究基于混合方法研究设计。使用 Stata 对定量数据进行描述性分析,数据来自从巴黎的 3 家医院收集的 100 名国内堕胎寻求者的调查,以及在荷兰(42 人)、西班牙(10 人)和英国(5 人)寻求堕胎护理的 57 名法国居民的调查。使用 ATLAS.ti 对定性数据进行主题分析,数据来自对 23 名国内堕胎寻求者和 13 名跨境堕胎旅行者的 36 名法国居民访谈。
妊娠期限(GA)限制是跨境旅行的关键原因,而附近缺乏及时和高质量的堕胎护理是国内堕胎旅行的主要驱动因素。与国内堕胎旅行者不同,跨境堕胎寻求者面临着与这种旅行相关的巨大经济成本和负担。伴侣、家庭成员和服务提供者为跨境和国内堕胎旅行者提供了重要的支持结构。
法律期限似乎是法国居民堕胎相关旅行的关键驱动因素。超过或即将超过 GA 限制导致女性前往国外或居住地以外的地方寻求堕胎护理。