Department of Biomedical and Clinical Sciences, Linköping University, Linköping, Sweden.
Department of Clinical Sciences, Lund, Logopedics, Phoniatrics, & Audiology, Lund, Sweden.
Int J Lang Commun Disord. 2023 Jul-Aug;58(4):1168-1181. doi: 10.1111/1460-6984.12850. Epub 2023 Jan 26.
The risks of developmental language disorder (DLD) for both educational progress and socio-emotional development are well documented, but little is known about how children and young people with DLD experience and describe their language and communication. The need to complement experimental and quantitative studies with qualitative perspectives of the lived experience of individuals with DLD for speech and language therapists (SLT) practice has recently been foregrounded.
To understand further the experiences of young people with DLD focusing on language and communication in a school context, and thereby contribute to the improvement of the communicative situation in school for this group. The study is guided by the following research question: How do young people diagnosed with DLD describe their experiences of language and communication in school?
METHODS & PROCEDURES: The study is based on data generated from qualitative semi-structured interviews with 23 participants diagnosed with DLD (age 13-19 years old) living in Sweden. All participants attended mainstream schools. To enable data to be collected during COVID-19 restrictions, all interviews were conducted using Zoom. Reflexive thematic analysis was used to analyse the data.
OUTCOMES & RESULTS: Four main themes related to experiences of language and communication in school were constructed from the interviews: (1) feelings of inadequacy and comparisons with others; (2) feelings of being misjudged and misunderstood; (3) the importance of feeling safe and comfortable; and (4) the significance of the social and communicative context. The results bear witness of difficult and challenging aspects related to language and communication in school, including educational, social and emotional dimensions. An important outcome of this study is how young people diagnosed with DLD describe their language and communication functioning to be dependent on both individual characteristics and abilities, as well as situational, contextual and social factors.
CONCLUSIONS & IMPLICATIONS: The results from this study show that young people with DLD can have persisting problems related to language and communication in school, including educational, social and emotional dimensions. SLT services may therefore be needed throughout the school years to ensure that students with DLD receive adequate support. In addition, support that goes beyond language abilities and targets social, contextual and emotional aspects should be considered.
What is already known on this subject Children and young people have unique knowledge about their language and communication which is instrumental for designing interventions and support strategies. Qualitative analyses of interview data have been able to identify both risk factors and protective strategies in relation to the well-being of individuals with DLD. Despite this, children and young people with DLD are rarely heard in research or clinical discussions. What this paper adds to existing knowledge In this study we listen to the voices of young people with DLD as they describe their experiences of language and communication in school. The participants describe a condition that makes them struggle to keep up with peers and puts them at risk of being misjudged by teachers, but also give examples of situations where negative consequences are hardly felt. What are the potential or actual clinical implications of this work? DLD is a complex and dynamic disorder where contextual and social factors interact with individual abilities in creating the end result. The results of the study indicate that DLD can cause persisting problems related to language and communication in school, with impact on educational, social and emotional dimensions. To counteract these effects, SLT services may be needed throughout the school years, and support that goes beyond language abilities must be considered.
发育性语言障碍(DLD)对教育进步和社会情感发展的风险已得到充分记录,但对于患有 DLD 的儿童和年轻人如何体验和描述他们的语言和沟通,知之甚少。最近,人们需要将实验和定量研究与言语和语言治疗师(SLT)实践中个体生活体验的定性观点结合起来。
更深入地了解患有 DLD 的年轻人在学校环境中语言和沟通的体验,从而改善该群体在学校的沟通状况。本研究的问题如下:被诊断患有 DLD 的年轻人如何描述他们在学校的语言和沟通体验?
本研究基于对 23 名(年龄 13-19 岁)居住在瑞典的被诊断患有 DLD 的参与者的定性半结构化访谈数据。所有参与者都就读于主流学校。为了能够在 COVID-19 限制期间收集数据,所有访谈均通过 Zoom 进行。采用反思性主题分析对数据进行分析。
从访谈中构建了四个与学校语言和沟通体验相关的主要主题:(1)不足感和与他人的比较;(2)被误解和误解的感觉;(3)感到安全和舒适的重要性;(4)社会和沟通环境的重要性。研究结果见证了与学校语言和沟通相关的困难和挑战方面,包括教育、社会和情感维度。本研究的一个重要结果是,被诊断患有 DLD 的年轻人如何描述他们的语言和沟通功能取决于个人特征和能力,以及情境、背景和社会因素。
本研究结果表明,患有 DLD 的年轻人在学校可能会持续存在与语言和沟通相关的问题,包括教育、社会和情感维度。因此,可能需要在整个学年提供 SLT 服务,以确保患有 DLD 的学生获得足够的支持。此外,应考虑针对社会、背景和情感方面的支持,而不仅仅是语言能力。