University of South Wales, Pontypridd, UK; Swansea Bay University Health Board, Port Talbot, UK.
SUDEP Action, Wantage, UK.
Seizure. 2023 Mar;106:14-21. doi: 10.1016/j.seizure.2023.01.007. Epub 2023 Jan 12.
Sudden Unexpected Death in Epilepsy (SUDEP) is a major concern for people with epilepsy, their families, their care givers, and medical professionals. There is inconsistency in the SUDEP counselling doctors provide, compared to what is recommended in clinical guidelines. Numerous national and international surveys have highlighted how epilepsy professionals, usually doctors, deliver SUDEP risk counselling, particularly, when they deliver it and to whom. These surveys help understand the unmet need, develop suitable strategies, and raise awareness among clinicians with the eventual goal to reduce SUDEPs. However, there is no standardised survey or essential set of questions identified that can be used to evaluate SUDEP counselling practice globally. This focused review analyses the content of all published SUDEP counselling surveys for medical professionals (n=16) to date covering over 4000 doctors across over 30 countries and five continents. It identifies 36 question themes across three topics. The questions are then reviewed by an expert focus group of SUDEP communication experts including three doctors, an expert statistician and SUDEP Action, an UK based charity specialising in epilepsy deaths with a pre-set criterion. The review and focus group provide ten essential questions that should be included in all future surveys inquiring on SUDEP counselling. They could be used to evaluate current practice and compare findings over time, between services, across countries and between professional groups. They are provided as a template to download and use. The review also explores if there is a continued need in future for similar surveys to justify this activity.
癫痫猝死 (SUDEP) 是癫痫患者、他们的家人、照顾者和医疗专业人员的主要关注点。与临床指南建议相比,医生提供的 SUDEP 咨询存在不一致性。许多国家和国际调查强调了癫痫专业人员(通常是医生)如何提供 SUDEP 风险咨询,特别是在何时以及向谁提供咨询。这些调查有助于了解未满足的需求,制定合适的策略,并提高临床医生的意识,最终目标是减少 SUDEPs。然而,目前还没有确定可以用于在全球范围内评估 SUDEP 咨询实践的标准化调查或基本问题集。本重点综述分析了迄今为止所有已发表的针对医疗专业人员的 SUDEP 咨询调查(n=16)的内容,这些调查涵盖了来自 30 多个国家和五个大陆的 4000 多名医生。它确定了三个主题下的 36 个问题主题。然后,由一个包括三名医生、一名专家统计学家和专门研究癫痫死亡的英国慈善机构 SUDEP Action 的 SUDEP 沟通专家组成的专家焦点小组对这些问题进行审查,该慈善机构设定了一个预设标准。该综述和焦点小组提供了未来所有关于 SUDEP 咨询调查都应包含的十个基本问题。它们可以用于评估当前的实践,并随着时间的推移、在服务之间、在国家之间以及在专业团体之间比较发现。它们被作为一个模板供下载和使用。该综述还探讨了未来是否需要继续进行类似的调查来证明这种活动的合理性。