Huh Sun
Department of Parasitology, Institute of Medical Education, College of Medicine, Hallym University, Chuncheon, Korea.
Neurointervention. 2023 Mar;18(1):2-8. doi: 10.5469/neuroint.2022.00493. Epub 2023 Feb 1.
In Korea, many editors of medical journal are also publishers; therefore, they need to not only manage peer review, but also understand current trends and policies in journal publishing and editing. This article aims to highlight some of these policies with examples. First, the use of artificial intelligence tools in journal publishing has increased, including for manuscript editing and plagiarism detection. Second, preprint publications, which have not been peer-reviewed, are becoming more common. During the COVID-19 pandemic, medical journals have been more willing to accept preprints to adjust rapidly changing pandemic health issues, leading to a significant increase in their use. Third, open peer review with reviewer comments is becoming more widespread, including the mandatory publication of peer-reviewed manuscripts with comments. Fourth, model text recycling policies provide guidelines for researchers and editors on how to appropriately recycle text, for example, in the background section of the Introduction or the Methods section. Fifth, journals should take into account the recently updated 4th version of the Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing, released in 2022. This version includes more detailed guidelines on journal websites, peer review processes, advisory boards, and author fees. Finally, it recommends that titles of human studies include country names to clarify the cultural context of the research. Each editor must decide whether to adopt these six policies for their journals. Editor-publishers of society journals are encouraged to familiarize themselves with these policies so that they can implement them in their journals as appropriate.
在韩国,许多医学期刊编辑同时也是出版商;因此,他们不仅需要管理同行评审,还需要了解期刊出版和编辑的当前趋势及政策。本文旨在通过实例突出其中一些政策。首先,人工智能工具在期刊出版中的使用有所增加,包括用于稿件编辑和抄袭检测。其次,未经同行评审的预印本出版物正变得越来越普遍。在新冠疫情期间,医学期刊更愿意接受预印本以应对迅速变化的疫情健康问题,导致其使用量大幅增加。第三,带有审稿人意见的公开同行评审正变得更加普遍,包括强制发表带有意见的同行评审稿件。第四,文本复用政策为研究人员和编辑提供了如何适当复用文本的指导方针,例如在引言或方法部分的背景部分。第五,期刊应考虑2022年发布的最新版《学术出版透明度与最佳实践原则》第4版。该版本包括关于期刊网站、同行评审流程、顾问委员会和作者费用的更详细指导方针。最后,它建议人体研究的标题应包含国家名称以阐明研究的文化背景。每位编辑必须决定是否在其期刊中采用这六项政策。鼓励学会期刊的编辑兼出版商熟悉这些政策,以便他们能在期刊中酌情实施。