Jiang Y H, Shen L, Liu Q B, Dai X Y, Sheng J, Liu X Y
Department of Surgery, Wuhan Pulmonary Hospital, Wuhan Institute for Tuberculosis Control, Wuhan 430030, China.
Zhonghua Wai Ke Za Zhi. 2023 Feb 1;61(2):156-161. doi: 10.3760/cma.j.cn112139-20220519-00231.
To examine the safety and efficacy of the uniportal video-assisted thoracoscopic decortication in treatment of drug-resistant tuberculosis empyema. From January 2018 to December 2020, 122 cases of tuberculous empyema treated by decortication in Department of Surgery, Wuhan Pulmonary Hospital were retrospectively analyzed, including 100 males and 22 females, aged((IQR)) 29.5(28.0) years (range: 13 to 70 years). According to the surgical approach and drug resistance, patients with drug-resistant tuberculosis who underwent uniportal video-assisted thoracoscopic decortication were included in group A (=22), and those who underwent thoracotomy decortication were included in group B (=28). Drug-sensitive patients who underwent uniportal video-assisted thoracoscopic decortication were included in group C (=72). There was no statistical difference in the baseline data of the three groups (>0.05). The operation, early postoperative recovery, and prognosis-related indicators were compared among three groups by Kruskal-Wallis test and test by Mann-Whitney test and Bonferroni method between groups A and B, groups A and C. The intraoperative blood loss of group A, group B, and group C was 200(475) ml, 300(200) ml, and 225(300) ml, respectively. There was no significant difference in intraoperative hemorrhage (=2.74, =0.254) and treatment outcome (=4.76, =0.575) among the three groups. Compared with group B, the operation time of group A (302.5(187.5) minutes 200.0(60.0) minutes, =171.0, =0.007) and postoperative pulmonary reexpansion duration (4.5(3.0) months 3.0 (2.2) months, =146.5, =0.032) were longer, and the postoperative drainage duration (9.5(7.8) days 13.0(10.0) days, =410.0, =0.044), and the postoperative hospitalization time (12.0(7.8) days 14.5(4.8) days, =462.2, =0.020) were shorter. There was no significant difference in complications between group A and group B (63.6%(14/22) 71.4%(20/28), =0.34, =0.558). Compared with group C, the postoperative drainage duration of group A (9.5(7.8) days 7.0(4.0) days, =543.5, =0.031), the postoperative hospitalization time (12.0(7.8) days 9.0(4.0) days, =533.0, =0.031) and postoperative pulmonary reexpansion duration (4.5(3.0) months 3.0(2.0) months, =961.5, =0.001) were longer. The operation time (302.5(187.5) minutes 242.5(188.8) minutes, =670.5, =0.278), and complications (63.6%(14/22) 40.3%(29/72), =3.70, =0.054) were not different between group A and group C. For drug-resistant tuberculous empyema, the uniportal video-assisted thoracoscopic decortication can achieve the same good therapeutic effect as drug-sensitive tuberculous empyema, and it is as safe as thoracotomy. At the same time, it has the advantage of minimally invasive and can accelerate the early postoperative recovery of patients.
探讨单孔电视辅助胸腔镜纤维板剥脱术治疗耐药性结核性脓胸的安全性和有效性。回顾性分析2018年1月至2020年12月武汉市肺科医院外科行纤维板剥脱术治疗的122例结核性脓胸患者,其中男性100例,女性22例,年龄(四分位间距)29.5(28.0)岁(范围:13至70岁)。根据手术方式和耐药情况,将行单孔电视辅助胸腔镜纤维板剥脱术的耐药性肺结核患者纳入A组(n = 22),行开胸纤维板剥脱术的患者纳入B组(n = 28)。行单孔电视辅助胸腔镜纤维板剥脱术的药物敏感患者纳入C组(n = 72)。三组患者的基线资料比较,差异无统计学意义(P>0.05)。采用Kruskal-Wallis检验对三组患者的手术、术后早期恢复及预后相关指标进行比较,采用Mann-Whitney检验和Bonferroni法对A组与B组、A组与C组之间进行组间比较。A组、B组和C组术中出血量分别为200(475)ml、300(200)ml和225(300)ml。三组患者术中出血(χ² = 2.74,P = 0.254)及治疗效果(χ² = 4.76,P = 0.575)差异均无统计学意义。与B组比较,A组手术时间(302.5(187.5)分钟比200.0(60.0)分钟,Z = 171.0,P = 0.007)及术后肺复张时间(4.5(3.0)个月比3.0(2.2)个月,Z = 146.5,P = 0.032)较长,术后引流时间(9.5(7.8)天比13.0(10.0)天,Z = 410.0,P = 0.044)及术后住院时间(12.0(7.8)天比14.5(4.8)天,Z = 462.2,P = 0.020)较短。A组与B组并发症发生率比较差异无统计学意义(63.6%(14/22)比71.4%(20/28),χ² = 0.34,P = 0.558)。与C组比较,A组术后引流时间(9.5(7.8)天比7.0(4.0)天,Z = 543.5,P = 0.031)、术后住院时间(12.0(7.8)天比9.0(4.0)天,Z = 533.0,P = 0.031)及术后肺复张时间(4.5(3.0)个月比3.0(2.0)个月,Z = 961.5,P = 0.001)较长。A组与C组手术时间(302.5(187.5)分钟比242.5(188.8)分钟,Z = 670.5,P = 0.278)及并发症发生率(63.6%(14/22)比40.3%(29/72),χ² = 3.70,P = 0.054)差异无统计学意义。对于耐药性结核性脓胸,单孔电视辅助胸腔镜纤维板剥脱术与药物敏感结核性脓胸可取得同样良好的治疗效果,且与开胸手术一样安全。同时,具有微创优势,可加速患者术后早期恢复。