End-of-life Care Research Group, Vrije Universiteit Brussel (VUB) and Ghent University, Brussels, Belgium.
Department of Medical Oncology, Ghent University, Ghent, Belgium.
PLoS One. 2023 Feb 1;18(2):e0273997. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0273997. eCollection 2023.
Measuring changes in the appropriateness of end-of-life care provided to patients with advanced illness such as cancer, COPD or dementia can help governments and practitioners improve service delivery and quality of life. However, an assessment of a possible shift in appropriateness of end-of-life care across the population is lacking.
Measuring quality indicators with routinely collected population-level data, this study aims to evaluate the appropriateness of end-of-life care for people with cancer, COPD or dementia in Belgium.
A population-level decedent cohort study, using data from eight population-level databases, including death certificate and health claims data. We measured validated sets of quality indicators for appropriateness of end-of-life care.
SETTING/PARTICIPANTS: All people who died from cancer or COPD or with dementia between 1st January 2010 and 1st January 2016 in Belgium.
We identified three main trends over time across the three disease groups of increasing use of: family physicians in the last 30 days of life (+21.7% in cancer, +33.7% in COPD and +89.4% in dementia); specialist palliative care in the last 14 days of life (+4.6% in cancer, +36.9% in COPD, +17.8% in dementia); and emergency department in the last 30 days of life (+7.0% in cancer, +4.4% in COPD and +8.2% in dementia).
Although we found an increase of both specialized palliative care and generalist palliative care use, we also found an increase in potentially inappropriate care, including ED and ICU admissions. To increase the quality of end-of-life care, both timely initiating (generalist and specialist) palliative care and avoiding potentially inappropriate care transitions, treatments and medications need to be quality performance targets.
衡量为患有晚期疾病(如癌症、COPD 或痴呆症)的患者提供的临终关怀的适宜性变化,可以帮助政府和从业者改善服务提供和生活质量。然而,对于人口中临终关怀适宜性的可能变化,还缺乏评估。
本研究使用常规收集的人群水平数据来衡量质量指标,旨在评估比利时癌症、COPD 或痴呆症患者的临终关怀适宜性。
一项人群水平的死亡队列研究,使用来自包括死亡证明和健康索赔数据在内的八个人群水平数据库的数据。我们测量了经验证的适宜性质量指标集。
设置/参与者:2010 年 1 月 1 日至 2016 年 1 月 1 日期间在比利时死于癌症或 COPD 或患有痴呆症的所有人。
我们在三个疾病组中发现了三个主要的时间趋势:在生命的最后 30 天内,家庭医生的使用增加(癌症增加 21.7%,COPD 增加 33.7%,痴呆症增加 89.4%);在生命的最后 14 天内,专科姑息治疗的使用增加(癌症增加 4.6%,COPD 增加 36.9%,痴呆症增加 17.8%);在生命的最后 30 天内,急诊部的使用增加(癌症增加 7.0%,COPD 增加 4.4%,痴呆症增加 8.2%)。
尽管我们发现专门的姑息治疗和全科姑息治疗的使用都有所增加,但我们也发现潜在的不适当护理增加,包括急诊部和 ICU 入院。为了提高临终关怀质量,需要将及时启动(全科和专科)姑息治疗和避免潜在不适当的护理转移、治疗和药物作为质量绩效目标。