IRCCS Fondazione Don Carlo Gnocchi, Milan, Italy.
Department of Physiopathology and Transplants, University of Milan, Milan, Italy.
Proc Inst Mech Eng H. 2023 Feb;237(2):199-208. doi: 10.1177/09544119221147956. Epub 2023 Feb 2.
Dynamic balance disorders are common impairments in People with Multiple Sclerosis (PwMS) leading to gait disorders and a higher risk of falling. However, the assessment of dynamic balance is still challenging and instrumented indexes provide objective and quantitative data of CoM movement and Base of Support, which are considered that are two key factors describing dynamic balance. This study aims at validating recent instrumented indexes based on the inverted pendulum model and characterizing dynamic balance disorders in PwMS. We clinically assessed 20 PwMS and we collected instrumented gait data through an optoelectronic system. Data from 20 Healthy Subjects (HS) were also considered as normative reference. Margin of Stability by HoF (MoS_Hof) and by Terry (MoS_Terry) at midstance, and Foot Placement Estimator (D) at heel strike were calculated in mediolateral (ML) and anteroposterior (AP) directions, for both less affected and most affected sides for PwMS and for dominant and non-dominant side for HS. MoS_HOF well discriminated between PwMS and HS, followed by MoS_TERRY in ML direction (Mos_HOF: PwMS = 130.0 ± 27.2 mm, HS = 106.5 ± 18.6 mm, < 0.001, MoS_TERRY: PwMS = 75.1 ± 24.3 mm, HS = 56.5 ± 23.4 mm, < 0.02). MoS_HOF and MoS_TERRY discriminated between sides in both directions in PwMS. D did not discriminate between groups and sides. Moderate correlations were found between all three indexes and clinical balance scales (from = 0.02 to = 0.66), energy recovery (from = -0.77 to = -0.11), single stance time (from = -0.11 to = 0.80) and step length (from = -0.83 to = -0.20). MoS_HOF resulted in the best index to describe dynamic balance disorders in PwMS: they keep CoM position far from the lateral and as close as possible to the anterior boundary of the Base of Support as preventive strategies to control balance perturbations. Furthermore, PwMS seem to use different preventive strategies in accordance with the specific lower limb impairments. This alters the physiological gait mechanisms increasing the energy expenditure and decreasing gait quality and dynamic balance.
动态平衡障碍是多发性硬化症患者(PwMS)常见的损伤,导致步态障碍和更高的跌倒风险。然而,动态平衡的评估仍然具有挑战性,仪器化指标提供了 CoM 运动和支撑基础的客观定量数据,这被认为是描述动态平衡的两个关键因素。本研究旨在验证基于倒立摆模型的最新仪器化指标,并描述 PwMS 的动态平衡障碍。我们对 20 名 PwMS 进行了临床评估,并通过光电系统收集了仪器化步态数据。还考虑了 20 名健康受试者(HS)的数据作为参考标准。在中足期,计算了横向(ML)和前后(AP)方向的中线摆动幅度(HoF 的 MoS_Hof)和 Terry 的 MoS_Terry,以及脚跟撞击时的足部放置估算值(D),用于 PwMS 的患侧和健侧,以及 HS 的优势侧和非优势侧。HoF 的 MoS_HOF 很好地区分了 PwMS 和 HS,其次是 ML 方向的 MoS_TERRY(HoF 的 MoS_HOF:PwMS=130.0±27.2mm,HS=106.5±18.6mm,<0.001,MoS_TERRY:PwMS=75.1±24.3mm,HS=56.5±23.4mm,<0.02)。HoF 的 MoS_HOF 和 MoS_TERRY 在 PwMS 中也区分了两侧。D 不能区分组和侧。所有三个指标与临床平衡量表(从 r=0.02 到 r=0.66)、能量恢复(从 r=-0.77 到 r=-0.11)、单足站立时间(从 r=-0.11 到 r=0.80)和步长(从 r=-0.83 到 r=-0.20)之间存在中度相关性。HoF 的 MoS_HOF 是描述 PwMS 动态平衡障碍的最佳指标:它们将 CoM 位置保持在远离外侧并尽可能靠近支撑基础的前边界,作为控制平衡扰动的预防策略。此外,PwMS 似乎根据特定的下肢损伤使用不同的预防策略。这改变了生理步态机制,增加了能量消耗并降低了步态质量和动态平衡。