Portnov A A, Rakitin M M, Ovsiannikov S A, Shamov S A, Timashkov V I
Zh Nevropatol Psikhiatr Im S S Korsakova. 1987;87(7):1076-82.
A study covering 277 psychopathic patients has been aimed at specifying the notion of psychopathy as well as the criteria of its diagnosis with the help of follow-up findings. Psychopathies are considered as a transient status of protracted adaptation due to retardation of the pubertal period. The study of "true" psychopathy has demonstrated that psychic disturbances are transitory and determined typologically by manifestations of neurosis or neurotic development. Persistent and prolonged psychopathy-like disturbances (n = 233) are referred to groups of other diseases.A total of 118 psychopathic patients have been subjected to a prolonged follow-up. The findings obtained have demonstrated a variety of organic cerebral diseases from traumatic encephalopathy to oligophrenia. The authors raise a question as to the validity of the generally accepted criteria of psychopathy in the framework of the so-called "organic psychopathy". A suggestion is put forward that abuse of the diagnosis of psychopathy in organic diseases of the central nervous system leads to the erroneous therapeutic strategy and corresponding social restrictions.
一项涵盖277名精神变态患者的研究旨在借助随访结果明确精神变态的概念及其诊断标准。精神变态被视为由于青春期发育迟缓导致的长期适应的一种短暂状态。对“真性”精神变态的研究表明,精神障碍是短暂的,并且在类型上由神经症或神经症性发展的表现所决定。持续且长期的类似精神变态的障碍(n = 233)被归类为其他疾病组。共有118名精神变态患者接受了长期随访。所获得的结果表明存在从创伤性脑病到智力发育迟缓等多种器质性脑部疾病。作者对在所谓“器质性精神变态”框架内普遍接受的精神变态标准的有效性提出了质疑。有人提出,在中枢神经系统器质性疾病中滥用精神变态的诊断会导致错误的治疗策略及相应的社会限制。