Husby Karen R, Gradel Kim O, Klarskov Niels
Urogynecology (Phila). 2023 Feb 1;29(2):121-127. doi: 10.1097/SPV.0000000000001264.
Concomitant surgery for stress urinary incontinence (SUI) during pelvic organ prolapse (POP) operations are debated.
We aimed to assess the risk of an SUI operation after a uterine prolapse operation and compare the risk after the Manchester procedure versus vaginal hysterectomy.
We performed a nationwide historical cohort study including women with no history of hysterectomy undergoing the Manchester procedure (n = 6065) or vaginal hysterectomy (n = 9,767) for POP during 1998 to 2018. We excluded women with previous surgery for SUI and POP, concomitant surgery for SUI (n = 34, 0.2%), and diagnosed with gynecological cancer before or within 90 days from surgery. Women were followed up until SUI operation/death/emigration/diagnosis of gynecological cancer/December 31, 2018, whichever came first. Women undergoing the Manchester procedure were censored if they had undergone hysterectomy.We assessed the rate of SUI surgery with cumulative incidence plots. We performed Cox Regression to analyze the risk of SUI surgery, adjusting for age, calendar year, income level, concomitant surgery in anterior and posterior compartments, and diagnosis of SUI before POP operation.
We found that 12.4% women with and 1.6% without SUI diagnosed before the POP surgery who underwent SUI surgery within 10 years.During follow-up (median, 8.5 years), 129 (2.1%) underwent SUI surgery after the Manchester procedure and 175 (1.8%) after vaginal hysterectomy (adjusted hazard ratio, 1.06 [0.84-1.35]).
Of women diagnosed with SUI before POP operation 1 in 8 subsequently underwent SUI surgery. Few women not diagnosed with SUI subsequently underwent SUI surgery. There was no difference in risk of SUI after the Manchester procedure and vaginal hysterectomy.
盆腔器官脱垂(POP)手术期间同时进行压力性尿失禁(SUI)手术存在争议。
我们旨在评估子宫脱垂手术后进行SUI手术的风险,并比较曼彻斯特手术与阴道子宫切除术后的风险。
我们进行了一项全国性的历史性队列研究,纳入了1998年至2018年期间因POP接受曼彻斯特手术(n = 6065)或阴道子宫切除术(n = 9767)且无子宫切除史的女性。我们排除了既往有SUI和POP手术史、同时进行SUI手术(n = 34,0.2%)以及在手术前或手术90天内被诊断为妇科癌症的女性。对女性进行随访,直至发生SUI手术/死亡/移民/诊断为妇科癌症/2018年12月31日,以先发生者为准。接受曼彻斯特手术的女性若进行了子宫切除术则被截尾。我们用累积发病率曲线评估SUI手术率。我们进行Cox回归分析SUI手术风险,并对年龄、日历年、收入水平、前后盆腔同时进行的手术以及POP手术前的SUI诊断进行校正。
我们发现,在POP手术前被诊断有SUI的女性中,12.4%在10年内接受了SUI手术,而未被诊断有SUI的女性中这一比例为1.6%。在随访期间(中位时间8.5年),129名(2.1%)在曼彻斯特手术后接受了SUI手术,175名(1.8%)在阴道子宫切除术后接受了SUI手术(校正风险比,1.06 [0.84 - 1.35])。
在POP手术前被诊断有SUI的女性中,八分之一的女性随后接受了SUI手术。很少有未被诊断有SUI的女性随后接受SUI手术。曼彻斯特手术和阴道子宫切除术后SUI的风险没有差异。