Goodban N A, Lieberman P B, Levine M A, Astrachan B M, Cocilovo V
Connecticut Mental Health Center, New Haven.
Am J Psychiatry. 1987 Nov;144(11):1437-43. doi: 10.1176/ajp.144.11.1437.
The authors compared the length of stay of acute admission patients at a mental health center and a nearby state hospital. The two facilities had significantly different length of stay distributions; the mean was not an adequate index to describe these patterns. Despite careful matching, patients at the state hospital were more disabled. Different patient characteristics were associated with length of stay at the two facilities, and these were also characteristics on which the patient populations differed at admission. The authors conclude that comparisons of hospitals, for example, on mean or median length of stay can be misleading unless the different functions, policies, and constraints of the facilities are taken into account.
作者比较了一家心理健康中心和附近一家州立医院急性入院患者的住院时间。这两家机构的住院时间分布存在显著差异;均值并非描述这些模式的合适指标。尽管进行了仔细匹配,但州立医院的患者残疾程度更高。不同的患者特征与两家机构的住院时间相关,而且这些也是患者入院时人群不同的特征。作者得出结论,例如,除非考虑到各机构不同的功能、政策和限制因素,否则基于平均或中位住院时间对医院进行比较可能会产生误导。