Bucini Gabriela, Clark Eric M, Merrill Scott C, Langle-Chimal Ollin, Zia Asim, Koliba Christopher, Cheney Nick, Wiltshire Serge, Trinity Luke, Smith Julia M
Department of Plant and Soil Science, University of Vermont, Burlington, VT, United States.
Social-Ecological Gaming and Simulation Lab, University of Vermont, Burlington, VT, United States.
Front Vet Sci. 2023 Jan 20;9:1067364. doi: 10.3389/fvets.2022.1067364. eCollection 2022.
The acceleration of animal disease spread worldwide due to increased animal, feed, and human movement has driven a growing body of epidemiological research as well as a deeper interest in human behavioral studies aimed at understanding their interconnectedness. Biosecurity measures can reduce the risk of infection, but human risk tolerance can hinder biosecurity investments and compliance. Humans may learn from hardship and become more risk averse, but sometimes they instead become more risk tolerant because they forget negative experiences happened in the past or because they come to believe they are immune. We represent the complexity of the hog production system with disease threats, human decision making, and human risk attitude using an agent-based model. Our objective is to explore the role of risk tolerant behaviors and the consequences of delayed biosecurity investments. We set up experiment with Monte Carlo simulations of scenarios designed with different risk tolerance amongst the swine producers and we derive distributions and trends of biosecurity and porcine epidemic diarrhea virus (PEDv) incidence emerging in the system. The output data allowed us to examine interactions between modes of risk tolerance and timings of biosecurity response discussing consequences for disease protection in the production system. The results show that hasty and delayed biosecurity responses or slow shifts toward a biosecure culture do not guarantee control of contamination when the disease has already spread in the system. In an effort to support effective disease prevention, our model results can inform policy making to move toward more resilient and healthy production systems. The modeled dynamics of risk attitude have also the potential to improve communication strategies for nudging and establishing risk averse behaviors thereby equipping the production system in case of foreign disease incursions.
由于动物、饲料和人员流动增加导致动物疾病在全球范围内传播加速,推动了越来越多的流行病学研究,以及人们对旨在理解它们之间相互联系的人类行为研究产生了更浓厚的兴趣。生物安全措施可以降低感染风险,但人类的风险承受能力可能会阻碍生物安全投资和合规行为。人类可能会从艰难经历中吸取教训,变得更加规避风险,但有时他们反而会变得更能容忍风险,因为他们忘记了过去发生的负面经历,或者因为他们开始相信自己具有免疫力。我们使用基于主体的模型来呈现生猪生产系统在疾病威胁、人类决策和人类风险态度方面的复杂性。我们的目标是探讨容忍风险行为的作用以及延迟生物安全投资的后果。我们通过蒙特卡洛模拟设置了实验,模拟了不同生猪生产者风险承受能力的情景,并得出系统中生物安全和猪流行性腹泻病毒(PEDv)发病率的分布和趋势。输出数据使我们能够研究风险容忍模式与生物安全响应时机之间的相互作用,讨论其对生产系统疾病防控的影响。结果表明,当疾病已经在系统中传播时,仓促和延迟的生物安全响应或向生物安全养殖方式的缓慢转变并不能保证控制污染。为了支持有效的疾病预防,我们的模型结果可为政策制定提供参考,以建立更具韧性和健康的生产系统。所模拟的风险态度动态变化还有可能改善引导和建立规避风险行为的沟通策略,从而在发生外来疾病入侵时使生产系统做好准备。