St. Petersburg City Multi-Field Hospital No. 2, St. Petersburg, Russia.
Mechnikov North-Western State Medical University, St. Petersburg, Russia.
Zh Vopr Neirokhir Im N N Burdenko. 2023;87(1):64-69. doi: 10.17116/neiro20238701164.
To date, microvascular decompression (MVD) and botulinum therapy (BT) confirm own efficacy in the treatment of hemifacial spasm (HFS). Quality of life (QOL) suffers first of all in these patients. Therefore, the dynamics of QOL indicators determines postoperative outcomes. Various researchers have proposed specialized scales for assessing QoL in HPS patients (HFS-7, HFS-8, HFS-30).
To analyze QOL in patients with HPS before and after MVD and BT including HFS-7 score and regression of HFS.
We analyzed data of patients (=80) divided into two groups: group I - MVD of the facial nerve (=66), group II - BT (=14). Mean age of patients was 52.4 (range 28-76) and 58.1 years (range 23-73), respectively. QOL was assessed using a questionnaire enrolling clinical and anamnestic data, as well as HFS-7 scale. Clinical severity of HFS and effect on daily activity were assessed using the Tan scale. We analyzed the results of MVD and BT considering clinical improvement (regression of spasm) and HFS-7 score. A four-level gradation of clinical regression of spasm was used.
Patients with mild course of disease and higher QOL prefer BT. In our sample, 3 (21%) patients from the 2 group preferred surgery a year after BT, and 13 (20%) patients from the 1 group had previously undergone BT in other hospitals. Changes in HFS-7 score before and after treatment were significant in both groups (<0.005, -test). Spearman's coefficient (R= -0.66) shows the correlation between clinical effect and HFS-7 score.
MVD and BT significantly improve QOL in patients suffering from HFS. Patients with less severe hemispasm prefer BT, but conversion to surgery is possible as disease progresses. Both treatment methods should be available for HFS patients. Treatment outcomes should be assessed using specialized scales designed for HFS.
分析微血管减压术(MVD)和肉毒杆菌毒素治疗(BT)前后 HFS 患者的生活质量(QOL),包括 HFS-7 评分和 HFS 缓解。
我们分析了 80 例患者的数据,分为两组:I 组 - 面神经 MVD(n = 66),II 组 - BT(n = 14)。患者的平均年龄分别为 52.4(28-76)岁和 58.1 岁(23-73)岁。使用问卷调查患者的临床和病史数据以及 HFS-7 评分来评估 QOL。使用 Tan 量表评估 HFS 的临床严重程度和对日常生活的影响。我们分析了 MVD 和 BT 的结果,考虑了临床改善(痉挛缓解)和 HFS-7 评分。使用痉挛临床缓解的四级分级。
疾病较轻和 QOL 较高的患者更喜欢 BT。在我们的样本中,2 组中有 3 例(21%)患者在 BT 一年后选择手术,1 组中有 13 例(20%)患者曾在其他医院接受过 BT。两组治疗前后 HFS-7 评分的变化均有统计学意义(<0.005,-检验)。Spearman 相关系数(R= -0.66)显示了临床疗效与 HFS-7 评分之间的相关性。
MVD 和 BT 可显著改善 HFS 患者的 QOL。病情较轻的患者更喜欢 BT,但随着病情的进展,可能需要转为手术。两种治疗方法都应可用于 HFS 患者。应使用专为 HFS 设计的专用量表评估治疗效果。