Roberts Morgan M, Perkins Stephanie D, Anderson Brian L, Sawyer Jason T, Brandebourg Terry D
Department of Animal Sciences, Auburn University, Auburn, AL 36849, USA.
Foods. 2023 Jan 26;12(3):554. doi: 10.3390/foods12030554.
European heritage breeds, such as the Blonde (B), Red (R), and Swallow-bellied (SB) Mangalica pig, display an extreme propensity to fatten and are reputed to produce superior quality pork. This suggests that Mangalica pork should command a higher price, and the Mangalica is a candidate breed to target niche markets within the United States. Our objectives were to test this hypothesis by (1) directly comparing growth performance and carcass merit of purebred Yorkshire (Y), B, R, and SB Mangalica pigs to identify the best breed for adoption, and (2) comparing indices of pork quality in purebred R, Y, and crossbred (R × Y) pigs to determine if crossbreeding represented a viable alternative to the adoption of purebred Mangalica. Daily feed intake, average daily gain (ADG), and feed efficiency were highest in Y and lowest in SB pigs with B and R ranked intermediately ( < 0.001). Backfat thickness was greatest in B and lowest in Y with R and SB ranked intermediately ( < 0.001). Marbling score was greatest in R pigs and lowest in Y pigs with B and SB ranked intermediately ( < 0.01). In contrast, loin eye area (LEA) was greatest in Y pigs compared to B, R, and SB ( < 0.001). Indices of meat quality were then compared in R, R × Y, and Y pigs. Backfat thickness and marbling scores were greater in R than R × Y and Y pigs ( < 0.001) while LEA was greater in Y than R × Y and R pigs ( < 0.001). Loin and ham ultimate pH, color, and firmness scores were significantly greater in R than R × Y or Y pigs ( < 0.05). Meanwhile, cook loss was significantly less in R than Y pigs ( < 0.007) while Warner-Bratzler Shear Force (WBS) was not different in chops between groups ( < 0.11). These data indicate that though Mangalica exhibit poorer growth performance, Mangalica pork exhibits superior pork quality attributes, suggesting that higher price points for Mangalica pork in niche markets are justified.
欧洲传统品种猪,如金色(B)、红色(R)和白腹(SB)曼加利察猪,具有极强的育肥倾向,且以产出高品质猪肉而闻名。这表明曼加利察猪肉应该能卖更高的价格,并且曼加利察猪是美国小众市场的候选目标品种。我们的目标是通过以下方式验证这一假设:(1)直接比较纯种约克夏(Y)、金色(B)、红色(R)和白腹(SB)曼加利察猪的生长性能和胴体品质,以确定最适合养殖的品种;(2)比较纯种红色(R)、约克夏(Y)以及杂交(R×Y)猪的猪肉品质指标,以确定杂交是否是替代养殖纯种曼加利察猪的可行选择。日采食量、平均日增重(ADG)和饲料效率在约克夏猪中最高,在白腹曼加利察猪中最低,金色和红色猪居中(P<0.001)。背膘厚度在金色猪中最大,在约克夏猪中最小,红色和白腹猪居中(P<0.001)。大理石纹评分在红色猪中最高,在约克夏猪中最低,金色和白腹猪居中(P<0.01)。相比之下,约克夏猪的眼肌面积(LEA)比金色、红色和白腹猪更大(P<0.001)。然后比较了红色、红×约和约克夏猪的肉质指标。红色猪的背膘厚度和大理石纹评分高于红×约和约克夏猪(P<0.001),而约克夏猪的眼肌面积大于红×约和红色猪(P<0.001)。红色猪的腰肉和火腿的最终pH值、颜色和硬度评分显著高于红×约或约克夏猪(P<0.05)。同时,红色猪的烹饪损失显著低于约克夏猪(P<0.007),而各组猪排之间的沃纳-布拉茨勒剪切力(WBS)没有差异(P<0.11)。这些数据表明,尽管曼加利察猪生长性能较差,但曼加利察猪肉具有优良的品质属性,这表明在小众市场中曼加利察猪肉定价更高是合理的。