Division of Urology Rainbow Babies and Children's Hospital/Case Western Reserve University School of Medicine, Cleveland, OH, USA.
Division of Urology, Children's Hospital of Philadelphia, PA, USA; Department of Biostatistics, Epidemiology and Informatics and Department of Surgery, University of Pennsylvania Perelman School of Medicine, Philadelphia, PA, USA.
J Pediatr Urol. 2023 Oct;19(5):514.e1-514.e7. doi: 10.1016/j.jpurol.2022.12.017. Epub 2023 Jan 6.
Antenatal hydronephrosis (ANH) is one of the most common anomalies identified on prenatal ultrasound, found in up to 4.5% of all pregnancies. Children with ANH are surveilled with repeated renal ultrasound and when there is high suspicion for a ureteropelvic junction obstruction on renal ultrasound, a mercaptuacetyltriglycerine (MAG3) Lasix renal scan is performed to evaluate for obstruction. However, the challenging interpretation of MAG3 renal scans places patients at risk of misdiagnosis.
Our objective was to analyze MAG3 renal scans using machine learning to predict renal complications. We hypothesized that our deep learning model would extract features from MAG3 renal scans that can predict renal complications in children with ANH.
We performed a case-control study of MAG3 studies drawn from a population of children with ANH concerning for ureteropelvic junction obstruction evaluated at our institution from January 2009 until June of 2021. The outcome was renal complications that occur ≥6 months after an equivocal MAG-3 renal scan. We created two machine learning models: a deep learning model using the radiotracer concentration versus time data from the kidney of interest and a random forest model created using clinical data. The performance of the models was assessed using measures of diagnostic accuracy.
We identified 152 eligible patients with available images of which 62 were cases and 90 were controls. The deep learning model predicted future renal complications with an overall accuracy of 73% (95% confidence inteveral [CI] 68-76%) and an AUC of 0.78 (95% CI 0.7, 0.84). The random forest model had an accuracy of 62% (95% CI 60-66%) and an AUC of 0.67 (95% CI. 0 64, 0.72) DISCUSSION: Our deep learning model predicted patients at high risk of developing renal complications following an equivocal renal scan and discriminate those at low risk with moderately high accuracy (73%). The deep learning model outperformed the clinical model built from clinical features classically used by urologists for surgical decision making.
Our models have the potential to influence clinical decision making by providing supplemental analytical data from MAG3 scans that would not otherwise be available to urologists. Future multi-institutional retrospective and prospective trials are needed to validate our model.
产前肾积水(ANH)是产前超声检查中最常见的异常之一,在所有妊娠中发现率高达 4.5%。患有 ANH 的儿童需要通过重复的肾脏超声检查进行监测,如果肾脏超声检查高度怀疑存在肾盂输尿管交界处梗阻,会进行 mercaptuacetyltriglycerine(MAG3)Lasix 肾扫描以评估梗阻情况。然而,MAG3 肾扫描的解读具有挑战性,这使患者面临误诊的风险。
我们的目标是使用机器学习分析 MAG3 肾扫描,以预测肾脏并发症。我们假设,我们的深度学习模型将从 MAG3 肾扫描中提取特征,这些特征可预测患有 ANH 的儿童的肾脏并发症。
我们进行了一项病例对照研究,研究对象为 2009 年 1 月至 2021 年 6 月在我们机构就诊的疑似肾盂输尿管交界处梗阻的 ANH 患儿的 MAG3 研究。该研究的结果是在不确定的 MAG3 肾扫描后≥6 个月发生的肾脏并发症。我们创建了两个机器学习模型:一个使用感兴趣肾脏的放射性示踪剂浓度与时间数据的深度学习模型,以及一个使用临床数据创建的随机森林模型。使用诊断准确性的测量来评估模型的性能。
我们确定了 152 名符合条件的患者,其中 62 名患者有图像,90 名患者作为对照。深度学习模型预测未来肾脏并发症的总体准确率为 73%(95%置信区间 [CI] 68-76%),AUC 为 0.78(95% CI 0.7,0.84)。随机森林模型的准确率为 62%(95% CI 60-66%),AUC 为 0.67(95% CI. 064,0.72)。
我们的深度学习模型预测出在不确定的肾脏扫描后有发生肾脏并发症高风险的患者,并以中等的高度准确性(73%)区分出低风险患者。该深度学习模型的表现优于泌尿科医生用于手术决策的经典临床特征构建的临床模型。
我们的模型有可能通过提供泌尿科医生无法获得的 MAG3 扫描的补充分析数据来影响临床决策。需要进行多机构回顾性和前瞻性试验来验证我们的模型。