Marín Victoria I, Buntins Katja, Bedenlier Svenja, Bond Melissa
Universitat de Lleida, Lleida, Spain.
University of Duisburg-Essen, Essen, Germany.
Educ Technol Res Dev. 2023 Feb 7:1-22. doi: 10.1007/s11423-023-10195-3.
Educational research is reflective of the nature and structure of national and regional education systems and their historical evolution. Educational technology research, as an area within educational research, reflects this case particularly prominently. Although individual countries and regions have varying research traditions, the publication of research in English as the scientific can lead to missing nuances in terminology, which is often not reflected upon. Despite this, the exploration of research from different countries can still uncover diverse topical clusters. This study aims to identify the research topics in educational technology research in three countries (Germany, Spain and the United Kingdom), each with their own research traditions, through the terms used. To this end, a bibliometric analysis of 3034 article abstracts and keywords from 29 English-language Web of Science journals in the field of education and educational research was conducted, with a focus on educational technology. In addition, the quantitative findings are comparatively analysed by considering the corresponding cultural clusters. Main findings include diverse research foci in the three countries, also showing that distinct research traditions are still present, despite using English as . Therefore, research articles written in English by non-English authors often do not reflect the same meanings in each country, despite using the same words. The conclusions reflect upon the need to establish ways of understanding the traditions behind those research articles and build collaborative systems to illustrate nuances in this research.
教育研究反映了国家和地区教育系统的性质、结构及其历史演变。教育技术研究作为教育研究的一个领域,这一情况体现得尤为突出。尽管各个国家和地区有着不同的研究传统,但以英语作为科学语言发表研究成果可能会导致术语细微差别缺失,而这一点常常未被反思。尽管如此,对不同国家研究的探索仍能揭示出多样的主题集群。本研究旨在通过所使用的术语,确定三个具有各自研究传统的国家(德国、西班牙和英国)教育技术研究中的研究主题。为此,对来自教育和教育研究领域29种英文科学引文索引期刊的3034篇文章摘要和关键词进行了文献计量分析,重点关注教育技术。此外,通过考虑相应的文化集群对定量研究结果进行了比较分析。主要研究结果包括这三个国家不同的研究重点,也表明尽管使用英语,但不同的研究传统仍然存在。因此,非英语作者用英语撰写的研究文章在每个国家往往并不反映相同的含义,尽管使用的是相同的词汇。结论反思了建立理解这些研究文章背后传统的方法以及构建协作系统以阐明本研究中细微差别的必要性。