Department of Cognitive Science, Central European University, Quellenstraße 51, 1100Wien,
Institute for Logic, Cognition, Language & Information, Carlos Santamaria Zentroa 2, Plaza de Elhuyar, 20018Donostia-San Sebastian, Spain.
Behav Brain Sci. 2023 Feb 17;46:e20. doi: 10.1017/S0140525X22001728.
One of our main goals with "Expression unleashed" was to highlight the distinctive, ostensive nature of human communication, and the many roles that ostension can play in human behavior and society. The commentaries we received forced us to be more precise about several aspects of this thesis. At the same time, no commentary challenged the central idea that the manifest diversity of human expression is underpinned by a common cognitive unity. Our reply is organized around six issues: (1) languages and their cultural evolution; (2) the pervasiveness of expression in human behavior; (3) artificial intelligence and ostensive communication; (4) communication in other animals; (5) the ecology and evolution of ostensive communication; and (6) biolinguistics and pragmatics.
我们的“表达的释放”的主要目标之一是强调人类交流的独特、明示性质,以及明示在人类行为和社会中可以发挥的多种作用。我们收到的评论迫使我们更准确地阐述这一论点的几个方面。同时,没有评论质疑这样一个核心观点,即人类表达的明显多样性是由共同的认知统一所支撑的。我们的回复围绕以下六个问题展开:(1)语言及其文化演变;(2)人类行为中表达的普遍性;(3)人工智能和明示交际;(4)其他动物的交流;(5)明示交际的生态和进化;(6)生物语言学和语用学。