Horiuchi Sayaka, Nomura Osamu, Curry Leslie, Kushima Megumi, Arnold Linda, Yamagata Zentaro
Department of Health Sciences, Division of Medicine, Graduate School Department of Interdisciplinary Research, University of Yamanashi, Yamanashi, Japan.
Department of Health Sciences Education, Hirosaki University, Aomori, Japan.
Child Care Health Dev. 2023 Nov;49(6):985-994. doi: 10.1111/cch.13107. Epub 2023 Mar 2.
Early detection of autism spectrum disorder (ASD) is essential to provide children with timely treatment and support. Evidence-based screening measures make it possible to identify children with suspected ASD at an early stage. Although Japan has a universal healthcare system that covers well-child visits, detection rates of developmental disorders, including ASD, at 18 months vary widely between municipalities (0.2%-48.0%). The reasons for this high level of variation are poorly understood. The present study aims to describe the barriers and facilitators of incorporating ASD identification during well-child visits in Japan.
This is a qualitative study that conducts semi-structured in-depth interviews in two municipalities of Yamanashi Prefecture. We recruited all public health nurses (n = 17) and paediatricians (n = 11) involved in the well-child visit in each municipality and caregivers of children who also participated in the visits during the study period (n = 21).
We identified four themes characterizing the process of ASD identification in the target municipalities: (1) Identification of children with ASD is driven by caregivers' sense of concern, acceptance and awareness. (2) Multidisciplinary cooperation and shared decision-making is limited. (3) Skills and training for developmental disabilities screening are underdeveloped. (4) Caregivers' expectations shape the interaction in important ways.
Non-standardization of screening methods, limited knowledge and skills on screening and child development among healthcare providers and poor coordination among healthcare providers and caregivers are the main barriers to effective early detection of ASD through well-child visits. The findings suggest the importance of promoting a child-centred care approach through the application of evidence-based screening measures and effective information sharing.
早期发现自闭症谱系障碍(ASD)对于为儿童提供及时治疗和支持至关重要。基于证据的筛查措施使早期识别疑似ASD儿童成为可能。尽管日本拥有覆盖儿童健康检查的全民医疗保健系统,但各市政当局18个月大儿童发育障碍(包括ASD)的检出率差异很大(0.2%-48.0%)。这种高度差异的原因尚不清楚。本研究旨在描述日本儿童健康检查中纳入ASD识别的障碍和促进因素。
这是一项定性研究,在山梨县的两个市政当局进行半结构化深度访谈。我们招募了参与各市政当局儿童健康检查的所有公共卫生护士(n = 17)和儿科医生(n = 11),以及在研究期间也参与检查的儿童的照顾者(n = 21)。
我们确定了目标市政当局中ASD识别过程的四个主题:(1)ASD儿童的识别由照顾者的关注感、接受度和意识驱动。(2)多学科合作和共同决策有限。(3)发育障碍筛查的技能和培训不发达。(4)照顾者的期望在重要方面塑造了互动。
筛查方法的不标准化、医疗保健提供者对筛查和儿童发育的知识和技能有限,以及医疗保健提供者与照顾者之间协调不佳,是通过儿童健康检查有效早期发现ASD的主要障碍。研究结果表明,通过应用基于证据的筛查措施和有效的信息共享来促进以儿童为中心的护理方法的重要性。