Hubbard J L, Scheithauer B W, Abboud C F, Laws E R
Department of Neurologic Surgery, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Minnesota.
J Neurosurg. 1987 Dec;67(6):816-21. doi: 10.3171/jns.1987.67.6.0816.
Controversy exists regarding the effects of bromocriptine on the success of transsphenoidal surgery for patients with prolactinomas. Various studies on this drug have reported adverse effects, improvement, and no effect upon the subsequent surgical outcome. The authors have retrospectively reviewed the case histories of 55 patients with immunocytochemically confirmed prolactin-secreting pituitary adenomas operated on by a transsphenoidal approach between 1981 and 1985. All patients had received bromocriptine in a variety of doses and for variable durations prior to surgery. Thirty-nine patients were women and 16 were men, with an age range of 8 to 72 years. Basal prolactin levels prior to bromocriptine treatment ranged from 38 to 100 ng/ml in 11 patients, from 101 to 200 ng/ml in 12, and greater than 200 ng/ml in 29. The "cure" rates were 54%, 58%, and 38%, respectively. Thirty-one patients had microadenomas, with a postoperative cure rate of 68%; 12 had diffuse expansive adenomas, with a 17% cure rate; and 12 had grossly invasive tumors, with a 17% cure rate. A response to preoperative bromocriptine therapy was defined as a return of the basal prolactin level to normal: 18 patients were responders and 29 were hyporesponders; in eight the data were not available. The postoperative cure rate was 50% for the responders and 31% for the hyporesponders. Taking into account the distribution of tumor type, there was no actual difference in outcome between the responder and the hyporesponder groups. The total bromocriptine dose received preoperatively was nearly identical for all groups. No significant differences in the frequency or extent of fibrosis, calcification, or prolactin immunoreactivity were observed in the 55 patients when compared with 26 control prolactinomas not treated with bromocriptine. It is concluded that short-term bromocriptine treatment does not adversely affect surgical outcome in any of the prolactin-secreting adenoma groups, nor does response or lack of response to bromocriptine predict surgical outcome.
关于溴隐亭对催乳素瘤患者经蝶窦手术成功率的影响,目前存在争议。针对这种药物的各类研究报告了其不良反应、改善情况以及对后续手术结果无影响等不同结论。作者回顾性分析了1981年至1985年间采用经蝶窦入路手术治疗的55例经免疫细胞化学确诊的分泌催乳素垂体腺瘤患者的病历。所有患者在手术前均接受了不同剂量和疗程的溴隐亭治疗。其中39例为女性,16例为男性,年龄范围在8岁至72岁之间。溴隐亭治疗前基础催乳素水平,11例患者为38至100 ng/ml,12例为101至200 ng/ml,29例大于200 ng/ml。“治愈”率分别为54%、58%和38%。31例患者为微腺瘤,术后治愈率为68%;12例为弥漫性扩张性腺瘤,治愈率为17%;12例为侵袭性大肿瘤,治愈率为17%。术前溴隐亭治疗有反应定义为基础催乳素水平恢复正常:18例患者有反应,29例反应欠佳;8例数据缺失。有反应者术后治愈率为50%,反应欠佳者为31%。考虑肿瘤类型分布,有反应组和反应欠佳组的手术结果实际并无差异。所有组术前接受的溴隐亭总剂量几乎相同。与26例未接受溴隐亭治疗的对照催乳素瘤相比,55例患者在纤维化、钙化频率或程度以及催乳素免疫反应性方面未观察到显著差异。研究得出结论,短期溴隐亭治疗对任何分泌催乳素腺瘤组的手术结果均无不利影响,对溴隐亭有反应或无反应也不能预测手术结果。