Tarozzi Ilaria, Franceschetti Lorenzo, Bugelli Valentina
Azienda USL Modena, U.O.C. Medicina Legale e Risk Management, 41126 Modena, Italy.
Istituto di Medicina Legale, Dipartimento di Scienze Biomediche per la Salute, Università degli Studi di Milano, 20122 Milano, Italy.
Healthcare (Basel). 2023 Feb 9;11(4):510. doi: 10.3390/healthcare11040510.
Fatal neck injuries represent a major challenge in forensic pathology because the anatomical complexity and high variability of neck structures make it often extremely difficult to differentiate true pathological findings from artifacts at autopsy. This topic becomes even more relevant when the forensic pathologist is required to make a pathophysiological evaluation of bone fractures in the absence of soft tissue to support the diagnosis. We report a case of unidentified, stone-covered, skeletonized human remains found within a pit below an abandoned building with bony lesions of the cervical spine and ribs, including a full-thickness fracture of the right lateral mass of the atlas (C1). After a careful study of the fractures was carried out by screening forensic literature and anthropological studies, clinical neurosurgical expertise was called upon to provide a reliable explanation. A rapid and violent twisting of the neck in the opposite direction from the fracture site by an attacker who pinned the victim's torso is the scenario that most likely occurred in our case. This case report shows that the diagnosis of cervical spine injuries in skeletal remains should be the result of a multidisciplinary approach that integrates forensic, anthropological, and clinical expertise.
致命性颈部损伤是法医病理学中的一项重大挑战,因为颈部结构的解剖复杂性和高度变异性使得在尸检时常常极难区分真正的病理发现与人为假象。当法医病理学家在缺乏软组织支持诊断的情况下需要对骨折进行病理生理评估时,这个问题就显得尤为重要。我们报告了一例身份不明的、被石块覆盖的、骨骼化的人类遗骸案例,该遗骸发现于一座废弃建筑物下方的坑内,颈椎和肋骨存在骨损伤,包括第一颈椎(C1)右侧块全层骨折。在通过筛选法医文献和人类学研究对骨折进行仔细研究后,我们邀请了临床神经外科专家提供可靠的解释。在我们的案例中,最有可能发生的情况是,袭击者固定住受害者的躯干,然后朝与骨折部位相反的方向快速猛烈地扭转其颈部。本病例报告表明,对骨骼遗骸中颈椎损伤的诊断应采用多学科方法,整合法医、人类学和临床专业知识。