Kasprzyk-Hordern Barbara, Sims Natalie, Farkas Kata, Jagadeesan Kishore, Proctor Kathryn, Wade Matthew J, Jones Davey L
Department of Chemistry, University of Bath, Claverton Down, Bath BA2 7AY, UK.
Department of Chemistry, University of Bath, Claverton Down, Bath BA2 7AY, UK.
J Hazard Mater. 2023 May 15;450:130989. doi: 10.1016/j.jhazmat.2023.130989. Epub 2023 Feb 17.
This manuscript showcases results from a large scale and comprehensive wastewater-based epidemiology (WBE) study focussed on multi-biomarker suite analysis of both chemical and biological determinants in 10 cities and towns across England equating to a population of ∼7 million people. Multi-biomarker suite analysis, describing city metabolism, can provide a holistic understanding to encompass all of human, and human-derived, activities of a city in a single model: from lifestyle choices (e.g. caffeine intake, nicotine) through to health status (e.g. prevalence of pathogenic organisms, usage of pharmaceuticals as proxy for non-communicable disease, NCD, conditions or infectious disease status), and exposure to harmful chemicals due to environmental and industrial sources (e.g. pesticide intake via contaminated food and industrial exposure). Population normalised daily loads (PNDLs) of many chemical markers were found, to a large extent, driven by the size of population contributing to wastewater (especially NCDs). However, there are several exceptions providing insights into chemical intake that can inform either disease status in various communities or unintentional exposure to hazardous chemicals: e.g. very high PNDLs of ibuprofen in Hull resulting from its direct disposal (confirmed by ibuprofen/2-hydroxyibuprofen ratios) and bisphenol A (BPA) in Hull, Lancaster and Portsmouth likely related to industrial discharge. An importance for tracking endogenous health markers such as 4-hydroxy-2-nonenal-mercapturic acid (HNE-MA, an oxidative stress marker) as a generic marker of health status in communities was observed due to increased levels of HNE-MA seen at Barnoldswick wastewater treatment plant that coincided with higher-than-average paracetamol usage and SARS-CoV-2 prevalence in this community. PNDLs of virus markers were found to be highly variable. Being very prevalent in communities nationwide during sampling, SARS-CoV-2 presence in wastewater was to a large extent community driven. The same applies to the fecal marker virus, crAssphage, which is very prevalent in urban communities. In contrast, norovirus and enterovirus showed much higher variability in prevalence across all sites investigated, with clear cases of localized outbreaks in some cities while maintaining low prevalence in other locations. In conclusion, this study clearly demonstrates the potential for WBE to provide an integrated assessment of community health which can help target and validate policy interventions aimed at improving public health and wellbeing.
本手稿展示了一项大规模、综合性的基于废水的流行病学(WBE)研究的结果,该研究聚焦于对英格兰10个城镇的化学和生物决定因素进行多生物标志物组分析,这些城镇的人口约为700万。描述城市新陈代谢的多生物标志物组分析可以在一个单一模型中提供全面的理解,以涵盖城市所有人类及人类衍生的活动:从生活方式选择(如咖啡因摄入、尼古丁)到健康状况(如致病生物的流行率、将药品使用作为非传染性疾病、慢性病状况或传染病状况的代理指标),以及因环境和工业来源而接触有害化学物质(如通过受污染食物摄入农药和工业接触)。发现许多化学标志物的人口标准化每日负荷(PNDLs)在很大程度上受排入废水的人口规模驱动(尤其是非传染性疾病)。然而,也有一些例外情况,这些情况为化学物质摄入提供了见解,可为不同社区的疾病状况或意外接触有害化学物质提供信息:例如,赫尔市布洛芬的PNDLs非常高,这是由于其直接排放(通过布洛芬/2 - 羟基布洛芬比率证实),而赫尔、兰卡斯特和朴茨茅斯的双酚A(BPA)可能与工业排放有关。由于在巴诺德斯威克污水处理厂观察到4 - 羟基 - 2 - 壬烯醛 - 巯基尿酸(HNE - MA,一种氧化应激标志物)水平升高,且该社区对乙酰氨基酚的使用高于平均水平以及新冠病毒流行率较高,因此观察到追踪内源性健康标志物(如HNE - MA)作为社区健康状况通用标志物的重要性。发现病毒标志物的PNDLs变化很大。在采样期间,新冠病毒在全国社区非常普遍存在,废水中新冠病毒的存在在很大程度上是由社区驱动的。粪便标志物病毒crAssphage也是如此,它在城市社区非常普遍。相比之下,诺如病毒和肠道病毒在所调查的所有地点的流行率变化要高得多,在一些城市有明显的局部暴发情况,而在其他地点则保持低流行率。总之,本研究清楚地证明了基于废水的流行病学在提供社区健康综合评估方面的潜力,这有助于针对并验证旨在改善公众健康和福祉的政策干预措施。