Department of Oncology, Thoraxklinik at Heidelberg University Hospital, Heidelberg, Germany.
Department of Medical Oncology, National Center for Tumor Diseases (NCT), Heidelberg University Hospital, Heidelberg, Germany.
Genes Chromosomes Cancer. 2023 Sep;62(9):557-563. doi: 10.1002/gcc.23135. Epub 2023 Mar 9.
Leveraging real-world data (RWD) for drug access is necessary to overcome a key challenge of modern precision oncology: tackling numerous low-prevalence oncogenic mutations across cancers. Withholding a potentially active medication in patients with rare mutations for the sake of control chemotherapy or "best" supportive care is neither practicable nor ethically justifiable anymore, particularly as RWD could meanwhile be used instead, according to scientific principles outlined by the US Food and Drug Administration, European Medicines Agency and other stakeholders. However, practical implementation varies, with occasionally opposite recommendations based on the same evidence in different countries. In the face of growing need for precision drugs, more transparency of evaluation, a priori availability of guidance for the academia and industry, as well as a harmonized framework for health technology assessment across the European Union (EU) are imperative. These could in turn trigger infrastructural changes in national and pan-European registries, cancer management guidelines (e.g., frequency of routine radiologic restaging, inclusion of patient-reported outcomes), and the health data space, to ensure conformity with declared standards and facilitate extraction of RWD sets (including patient-level data) suitable for approval and pricing with minimal effort. For an EU-wide unification of precision cancer medicine, collective negotiation of drug supply contracts and funding solidarity would additionally be required to handle the financial burden. According to experience from pivotal European programs, off-label use could potentially also be harmonized across EU-states to accelerate availability of novel drugs, streamline collection of valuable RWD, and mitigate related costs through wider partnerships with pharmaceutical companies.
利用真实世界数据(RWD)来获取药物对于克服现代精准肿瘤学的一个关键挑战是必要的:解决癌症中众多低患病率的致癌突变。为了控制化疗或“最佳”支持性护理而拒绝为罕见突变的患者提供潜在有效的药物,既不可行,也不符合伦理,尤其是因为 RWD 可以根据美国食品和药物管理局、欧洲药品管理局和其他利益相关者概述的科学原则来使用。然而,实际实施情况存在差异,在不同国家,根据相同的证据偶尔会提出相反的建议。面对对精准药物日益增长的需求,更透明的评估、为学术界和行业提供事先可用的指导以及在整个欧盟(EU)内对卫生技术评估的协调框架都是至关重要的。这反过来又可以触发国家和泛欧登记处、癌症管理指南(例如,常规放射学重新分期的频率、患者报告结果的纳入)以及卫生数据空间的基础设施变化,以确保符合既定标准并便于提取适合最小努力进行批准和定价的 RWD 集(包括患者水平数据)。为了实现欧盟范围内精准癌症医学的统一,还需要进行集体谈判,以处理药物供应合同和资金团结问题,以应对财务负担。根据欧洲关键项目的经验,跨欧盟国家也可以协调药物的标签外使用,以加快新药的供应,简化有价值的 RWD 的收集,并通过与制药公司建立更广泛的伙伴关系来减轻相关成本。