REVAL - Rehabilitation Research Centre, Faculty of Rehabilitation Sciences, Hasselt University, Diepenbeek, Belgium.
Heart Centre Hasselt, Jessa Hospital, Hasselt, Belgium.
Med Educ Online. 2023 Dec;28(1):2182660. doi: 10.1080/10872981.2023.2182660.
Exercise prescriptions by clinicians to patients with cardiovascular disease (CVD) often disagree with recommendations, thus requiring improvement.
To assess whether exercise prescriptions by physiotherapists to patients with CVD are better in agreement with European (ESC/EAPC) recommendations when the EXPERT (EXercise Prescription in Everyday practice & Rehabilitative Training) Training tool is used for digital educational training.
In a prospective non-randomized intervention study.
Twenty-three belgian physiotherapists first prescribed exercise intensity, frequency, session duration, program duration and exercise type (endurance or strength training) for the same three patient cases, from which the agreement with ESC/EAPC recommendations (based on a maximal score of 60/per case: agreement score) was assessed. Next, they completed a one-month digital training by using the EXPERT Training tool and completed 31 ± 13 training cases. The EXPERT tool is a training and decision support system that automatically generates a (personalised) exercise prescription according to the patient's characteristics, thus integrating the exercise prescriptions for different CVDs and risk factors, all based on ESC/EAPC recommendations. Thereafter, the same three patient cases as at entry of study were filled out again, with re-assessment of level of agreement with ESC/EAPC recommendations.
After using the EXPERT Training tool, the physiotherapists prescribed significantly greater exercise frequencies, program durations and total exercise volumes in all three patient cases ( < 0.05). In cases 1, 2 and 3, the agreement score increased from 29 ± 9 (out of 60), 28 ± 9, and 34 ± 7 to 41 ± 9, 41 ± 10, and 45 ± 8, respectively ( < 0.001). Hence, the total agreement score increased from 91 ± 17 (out of 180) to 127 ± 19 ( < 0.001, +44 ± 32%). A lower starting agreement score and younger age correlated with a greater improvement in total agreement score ( < 0.05).
Exercise prescriptions to patients with CVD, generated by physiotherapists, are significantly better in agreement with European recommendations when the EXPERT Training tool is used, indicating its educational potential.
临床医生为心血管疾病 (CVD) 患者开出的运动处方常常与建议不符,因此需要改进。
评估在使用 EXPERT(日常实践中的运动处方和康复训练)培训工具进行数字教育培训时,物理治疗师为 CVD 患者开出的运动处方是否更符合欧洲 (ESC/EAPC) 建议。
前瞻性非随机干预研究。
23 名比利时物理治疗师首先为三个相同的患者病例开出运动强度、频率、每次运动时长、运动周期和运动类型(耐力训练或力量训练),然后根据 ESC/EAPC 建议(基于每个病例的最大分数 60/分:一致评分)评估与建议的一致程度。接下来,他们使用 EXPERT 培训工具完成了一个为期一个月的数字培训,并完成了 31±13 个培训病例。EXPERT 工具是一个培训和决策支持系统,根据患者的特点自动生成个性化的运动处方,从而整合了不同 CVD 和风险因素的运动处方,所有这些都基于 ESC/EAPC 建议。然后,再次填写最初的三个患者病例,重新评估与 ESC/EAPC 建议的一致程度。
使用 EXPERT 培训工具后,所有三个患者病例的运动频率、运动周期和总运动量均显著增加( < 0.05)。在病例 1、2 和 3 中,一致评分分别从 29±9(满分 60 分)、28±9 和 34±7 增加到 41±9、41±10 和 45±8( < 0.001)。因此,总一致评分从 91±17(满分 180 分)增加到 127±19( < 0.001,增加 44±32%)。较低的起始一致评分和较年轻的年龄与总一致评分的更大改善相关( < 0.05)。
当使用 EXPERT 培训工具时,由物理治疗师为 CVD 患者开出的运动处方与欧洲建议的一致性显著提高,表明其具有教育潜力。