School of Nursing, Midwifery and Paramedicine, Australian Catholic University, Fitzroy, Victoria, Australia.
NorthWestern Mental Health, Melbourne Health, Parkville, Victoria, Australia.
Int J Ment Health Nurs. 2023 Aug;32(4):1055-1071. doi: 10.1111/inm.13132. Epub 2023 Feb 28.
Mental health nursing work is challenging, and workplace stress can have negative impacts on nurses' well-being and practice. Resilience is a dynamic process of positive adaptation and recovery from adversity. The aims of this integrative review were to examine and update understandings and perspectives on resilience in mental health nursing research, and to explore and synthesize the state of empirical knowledge on mental health nurse resilience. This is an update of evidence from a previous review published in 2019. Using integrative review methodology, 15 articles were identified from a systematic search (July 2018-June 2022). Data were extracted, analysed with constant comparison method, synthesized narratively and then compared with the findings from the original review. As an update of evidence, mental health nurse resilience was moderate to high across studies, was positively associated with psychological well-being, post-traumatic growth, compassion satisfaction and negatively associated with burnout, mental distress and emotional labour. Lack of support and resources from organizations could negatively impact nurses' ability to maintain resilience and manage workplace challenges through internal self-regulatory processes. A resilience programme improved mental health nurses' awareness of personal resilience levels, self-confidence, capacity to develop coping skills and professional relationships. Some studies continue to lack contemporary conceptualizations of resilience, and methodological quality varied from high to low. Further qualitative and interventional research is needed to investigate the role of resilience in mental health nursing practice, personal well-being, workforce sustainability and the ongoing impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic.
精神科护理工作具有挑战性,工作场所压力会对护士的身心健康和工作实践产生负面影响。韧性是个体从逆境中积极适应和恢复的动态过程。本综述的目的是检验和更新精神科护理研究中对韧性的理解和观点,并探讨和综合精神科护士韧性的实证知识现状。这是对 2019 年发表的先前综述的证据更新。采用综合综述方法,从系统检索(2018 年 7 月至 2022 年 6 月)中确定了 15 篇文章。提取数据,采用恒定性比较方法进行分析,以叙述方式综合,并与原始综述的结果进行比较。作为证据更新,精神科护士的韧性在研究中处于中等至高水平,与心理幸福感、创伤后成长、同情心满足感呈正相关,与倦怠、精神困扰和情绪劳动呈负相关。组织缺乏支持和资源可能会对护士通过内部自我调节过程维持韧性和应对工作场所挑战的能力产生负面影响。一项韧性计划提高了精神科护士对个人韧性水平、自信、发展应对技能和专业关系的能力的认识。一些研究仍然缺乏对韧性的当代概念化,方法学质量从高到低不等。需要进一步进行定性和干预研究,以调查韧性在精神科护理实践、个人幸福感、劳动力可持续性以及 COVID-19 大流行持续影响中的作用。