Andrews B T, Levy M L, Pitts L H
Department of Neurosurgery, School of Medicine, University of California, San Francisco.
Surg Neurol. 1987 Dec;28(6):419-22. doi: 10.1016/0090-3019(87)90223-0.
Thirty-six patients admitted with severe head injury and various degrees of systemic hypotension were studied to determine the effect of hypotension on the validity of the neurological examination in reflecting mechanical brain compression. All patients had clinical signs of transtentorial herniation or upper brainstem compression and underwent immediate bilateral placement of exploratory burr holes for the diagnosis and removal of intracranial hematomas. All patients were initially hypotensive: 10 were in cardiac arrest, 7 had a systolic blood pressure (SBP) less than 60 torr, and 19 had SBP of 60-90 torr. The median score on the Glascow coma scale was 3 (range 3-8). Although 4 of the 10 cardiac arrest patients had anisocoria, only one (10%) had an intracranial hematoma. Among the seven patients with severe hypotension, only two had anisocoria and neither had and intracranial hematoma; one patient in this group (14%) had a hematoma that was diagnosed at autopsy. In contrast, intracranial hematomas were discovered by burr-hole placement and evacuated in 13 (68%) of 19 patients with initially moderate hypotension, including seven (78%) of nine patients with anisocoria. Anisocoria was associated with mechanical brain compression from an intracranial hematoma significantly more often in patients with an initial SBP of 60-90 torr than in those with initial cardiac arrest or SBP less than 60 torr (chi-square p less than 0.05). Intracranial hematomas were significantly more frequent among patients with SBP of 60-90 torr than among those with a lower SBP or initial cardiac arrest (P less than 0.01). Thirty-three of 36 patients died; each of the three survivors had an initial SBP of 60-90 torr, and hematomas were removed in two. In head-injured patients with SBP greater than 60 torr, clinical signs of tentorial herniation or upper brainstem dysfunction remain valid indicators of possible mechanical compression; the high percentage of patients with acute intracranial hematomas in this group warrants immediate diagnostic burr-hole exploration. In patients with severe initial hypotension (SBP less than 60 torr) or cardiac arrest, clinical findings of brainstem dysfunction cannot be relied upon to indicate mechanical compression, and computed tomography scanning should be done immediately after resuscitation to determine the need for surgical exploration.
对36例因重度颅脑损伤合并不同程度全身性低血压入院的患者进行了研究,以确定低血压对神经学检查反映机械性脑压迫有效性的影响。所有患者均有小脑幕切迹疝或上脑干受压的临床体征,并立即接受双侧钻孔探查,以诊断和清除颅内血肿。所有患者最初均为低血压:10例心脏骤停,7例收缩压(SBP)低于60托,19例SBP为60 - 90托。格拉斯哥昏迷量表的中位数评分为3分(范围3 - 8分)。虽然10例心脏骤停患者中有4例存在瞳孔不等大,但只有1例(10%)有颅内血肿。在7例重度低血压患者中,只有2例有瞳孔不等大,且均无颅内血肿;该组中有1例患者(14%)在尸检时被诊断有血肿。相比之下,在19例最初为中度低血压的患者中,有13例(68%)通过钻孔探查发现并清除了颅内血肿,其中9例瞳孔不等大的患者中有7例(78%)。与最初心脏骤停或SBP低于60托的患者相比,最初SBP为60 - 90托的患者中,瞳孔不等大与颅内血肿导致的机械性脑压迫明显更相关(卡方检验p值小于0.05)。SBP为60 - 90托的患者中颅内血肿明显比SBP较低或最初心脏骤停的患者更常见(P小于0.01)。36例患者中有33例死亡;3例幸存者最初SBP均为60 - 90托,其中2例清除了血肿。在SBP大于60托的颅脑损伤患者中,小脑幕切迹疝或上脑干功能障碍的临床体征仍然是可能存在机械性压迫的有效指标;该组急性颅内血肿患者的高比例值得立即进行诊断性钻孔探查。在最初有严重低血压(SBP低于60托)或心脏骤停的患者中,脑干功能障碍的临床发现不能用于提示机械性压迫,复苏后应立即进行计算机断层扫描,以确定是否需要手术探查。