Benishek Lauren E, Radonovich Lewis J, Blackley Brie H, Weissman David N
Armstrong Institute for Patient Safety and Quality, Johns Hopkins School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland.
Respiratory Health Division, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Morgantown, West Virginia.
Antimicrob Steward Healthc Epidemiol. 2023 Feb 15;3(1):e29. doi: 10.1017/ash.2022.276. eCollection 2023.
To understand healthcare worker (HCW) perceptions of infection risk associated with aerosol-generating procedures (AGPs) and their affective response to performing AGPs.
Systematic review.
Systematic searches of PubMed, CINHAL Plus, and Scopus were conducted using combinations of selected keywords and synonyms. To reduce bias, titles and abstracts were screened for eligibility by 2 independent reviewers. Also, 2 independent reviewers extracted data from each eligible record. Discrepancies were discussed until consensus was reached.
In total, 16 reports from across the globe were included in this review. Findings suggest that AGPs are generally perceived to place HCWs at high risk of becoming infected with respiratory pathogens and that this perception stimulates a negative affective response and hesitancy to participate in the procedures.
AGP risk perception are complex and context dependent but have important influences on HCW infection control practices, decision to participate in AGPs, emotional welfare, and workplace satisfaction. New and unfamiliar hazards paired with uncertainty lead to fear and anxiety about personal and others' safety. These fears may create a psychological burden conducive to burnout. Empirical research is needed to thoroughly understand the interplay between HCW risk perceptions of distinct AGPs, their affective responses to conducting these procedures under various conditions, and their resulting decision to participate in these procedures. Results from such studies are essential for advancing clinical practice; they point to methods for mitigating provider distress and better recommendations for when and how to conduct AGPs.
了解医护人员对与产生气溶胶操作(AGP)相关的感染风险的认知以及他们对执行AGP的情感反应。
系统评价。
使用选定的关键词及其同义词组合,对PubMed、CINHAL Plus和Scopus进行系统检索。为减少偏倚,由2名独立评审员筛选标题和摘要以确定其是否符合纳入标准。此外,2名独立评审员从每条符合条件的记录中提取数据。如有分歧则进行讨论,直至达成共识。
本评价共纳入了来自全球的16份报告。研究结果表明,医护人员普遍认为AGP会使他们面临感染呼吸道病原体的高风险,这种认知会引发负面的情感反应以及对参与这些操作的犹豫。
对AGP风险的认知复杂且因情况而异,但对医护人员的感染控制措施、参与AGP的决定、情绪健康和工作场所满意度有重要影响。新的和不熟悉的危害加上不确定性会导致对个人和他人安全的恐惧和焦虑。这些恐惧可能会造成导致职业倦怠的心理负担。需要进行实证研究,以全面了解医护人员对不同AGP的风险认知、他们在各种情况下对执行这些操作的情感反应以及他们参与这些操作的最终决定之间的相互作用。此类研究的结果对于推进临床实践至关重要;它们指出了减轻医护人员痛苦的方法,以及关于何时以及如何进行AGP的更好建议。