Panjab University, India.
Birbal Sahni Institute of Paleosciences (BSIP), India.
Med Sci Law. 2023 Oct;63(4):298-308. doi: 10.1177/00258024231159591. Epub 2023 Mar 7.
Stable isotope analysis from bones and teeth has been widely used to estimate the likely geographic locations and dietary status of individuals whose osseous remains have been retrieved from some forensic or bio-archaeological contexts. The carbon and nitrogen stable isotope signatures can provide insights into geographic affinity and dietary habits. Ajnala skeletal remains represent a serious crime against humanity committed in past by colonial rulers and by amateur archaeologists of modern times. In present study, isotopic concentrations of carbon δC) and nitrogen δN) estimated from 21 mandibular molars have been used to estimate the local or non-local status of badly damaged skeletal remains retrieved from an abandoned well at Ajnala (India). The collagen samples having C/N ratio within range of 2.8-3.6 were considered as well-preserved and non-contaminated ones. The isotope concentrations of carbon and nitrogen varied from -18.7‰ to -22.9‰ and +7.6‰ to +11.7‰, with an average of -20.49 ± 1.2‰ and +9.31 ± 1.1‰, respectively. The analysis of the obtained isotope values reflected the consumption of C/C mixed diet by majority of the individuals, and such type of dietary habits are mainly restricted to the reported Indo-Gangatic plain of India to which slain soldiers reportedly belonged to. These observations corroborated the previous observations about the geographic affinity and dietary status of Ajnala individuals. Though C and N isotopes are by and large not the confirmed/direct indicators of geographic origin, they can provide corroboratory information to support other observations narrowing down the dietary habits of individuals of certain specific geographical regions.
从骨骼和牙齿中进行稳定同位素分析已被广泛用于估计从法医或生物考古学背景中获取的骨骼遗骸的个体可能的地理位置和饮食状况。碳和氮稳定同位素特征可以提供有关地理亲缘关系和饮食习惯的见解。Ajnala 的骨骼遗骸代表了过去殖民统治者和现代业余考古学家犯下的严重反人类罪行。在本研究中,从 21 个下颌磨牙中估算出的碳(δC)和氮(δN)的同位素浓度,用于估计从 Ajnala(印度)一口废弃的井中获取的严重受损骨骼遗骸的本地或非本地状况。C/N 比在 2.8-3.6 范围内的胶原样品被认为是保存完好且未受污染的样品。碳和氮的同位素浓度范围从-18.7‰到-22.9‰和+7.6‰到+11.7‰,平均值分别为-20.49±1.2‰和+9.31±1.1‰。获得的同位素值分析反映了大多数个体食用 C/C 混合饮食,这种饮食习惯主要局限于印度报告的印度-恒河平原,据报道,被杀害的士兵就属于这一地区。这些观察结果证实了以前关于 Ajnala 个体的地理亲缘关系和饮食状况的观察结果。尽管碳和氮同位素总体上不是地理起源的确认/直接指标,但它们可以提供补充信息,以支持其他观察结果,从而缩小某些特定地理区域个体的饮食习惯。