Topp Robert, Greenstein Jay, Etnoyer-Slaski Jena
College of Nursing, The University of Toledo, Toledo, OH, United States.
Kaizo Clinical Research Institute, Rockville, MD, United States.
JMIR Rehabil Assist Technol. 2023 Mar 28;10:e43507. doi: 10.2196/43507.
A significant number of patients do not adhere to their prescribed course of physical therapy or discharge themselves from care. Adhering to prescribed physical therapy, including attending physical therapy clinic appointments, contributes to patients achieving the goals of therapy including reducing pain and increasing functionality. Web-based platforms have been demonstrated to be effective means for managing clinical patients with musculoskeletal pain, similar to managing them in person. Behavior change techniques introduced through digital or web-based platforms can reduce nonadherence with prescribed physical therapy and improve patient outcomes. Literature also indicates that a phone-based app provided to patients, which includes a reward-incentive gamification to complement their care, contributed to a greater number of kept appointments in a physical therapy clinic.
This study aims to compare the rate of provider discharge with self-discharge and the number of clinic visits among patients attending a physical health clinic who did and did not choose to adopt a phone-based app to complement their care. A secondary purpose was to compare the revenue generated by patients attending a physical health clinic who did and did not choose to adopt a phone-based app to complement their care.
A retrospective analysis of all new outpatient medical records (N=5328) from a multisite physical health practice was conducted between January 2018 and December 2019. Patients in the sample self-selected the 2018 Usual Care, the 2019 Usual Care, or the 2019 Kanvas App groups. Kanvas is a customized private practice app, designed for patient engagement with their specific health care provider. This app included a gamification system that provided rewards to the patient for attending their scheduled clinic appointments. According to their medical record, each patient was classified as completing their prescribed therapy (provider discharged) or not completing their prescribed therapy (self-discharged). Additionally, the total number of clinic visits each patient attended, the total charges for services, and the total payments received by the clinic per patient were extracted from each patient's medical record.
Patients in the 2019 Kanvas App Group exhibited a higher rate of provider discharge compared to patients who did not adopt the app. This greater rate of provider discharges among the patients who adopted the Kanvas app likely contributed to this group attending more clinic visits (13.21, SD 12.09) than the other study groups who did not download the app (10.72, SD 9.80 to 11.35, SD 11.10). This greater number of clinic visits in turn contributed to the patients who adopted the app generating more clinic charges and payments.
Future investigators need to employ more rigorous methods to confirm these findings, and clinicians need to weigh the anticipated benefits against the cost and staff involvement in managing the Kanvas app.
相当多的患者不坚持其规定的物理治疗疗程,或自行停止治疗。坚持规定的物理治疗,包括按时前往物理治疗诊所就诊,有助于患者实现治疗目标,如减轻疼痛和提高功能。基于网络的平台已被证明是管理肌肉骨骼疼痛临床患者的有效手段,类似于亲自管理患者。通过数字或基于网络的平台引入的行为改变技术可以减少对规定物理治疗的不依从性,并改善患者的治疗效果。文献还表明,向患者提供的基于手机的应用程序,其中包括奖励激励游戏化以辅助其治疗,有助于患者在物理治疗诊所保持更多的预约就诊。
本研究旨在比较在一家身体健康诊所就诊的患者中,采用和未采用基于手机的应用程序辅助治疗的患者的医生安排出院率与自行出院率,以及诊所就诊次数。第二个目的是比较在一家身体健康诊所就诊的采用和未采用基于手机的应用程序辅助治疗的患者所产生的收入。
对2018年1月至2019年12月期间一家多地点身体健康医疗机构的所有新门诊病历(N = 5328)进行回顾性分析。样本中的患者自行选择进入2018年常规治疗组、2019年常规治疗组或2019年Kanvas应用程序组。Kanvas是一款定制的私人执业应用程序,旨在促进患者与他们的特定医疗服务提供者互动。该应用程序包括一个游戏化系统,为按时前往诊所就诊的患者提供奖励。根据病历,将每位患者分类为完成规定治疗(医生安排出院)或未完成规定治疗(自行出院)。此外,从每位患者的病历中提取每位患者的诊所就诊总次数、服务总费用以及诊所收到的每位患者的总付款。
与未采用该应用程序的患者相比,2019年Kanvas应用程序组的患者医生安排出院率更高。采用Kanvas应用程序的患者中更高的医生安排出院率可能导致该组患者的诊所就诊次数(13.21,标准差12.09)多于未下载该应用程序的其他研究组(10.72,标准差9.80至11.35,标准差11.10)。就诊次数的增加反过来导致采用该应用程序的患者产生更多的诊所费用和付款。
未来的研究人员需要采用更严格的方法来证实这些发现,临床医生需要权衡预期的益处与管理Kanvas应用程序的成本和工作人员投入。