Čapek R, Musil D, Nevšímal L, Sadovský P, Trnka T
Ortopedické oddělení Nemocnice České Budějovice, a.s.
Acta Chir Orthop Traumatol Cech. 2023;90(1):9-16.
PURPOSE OF THE STUDY The study retrospectively reviews the outcomes of patella stabilisation surgeries performed at our department in the period 2010-2020. It aimed to provide a more thorough evaluation, to compare the respective types of MPFL reconstruction and to confirm the beneficial effect of tibial tubercle ventromedialization on patella height. MATERIAL AND METHODS In the period 2010-2020, a total of 72 stabilisation surgeries of patellofemoral joint in 60 patients with objective patellar instability (OPI) were performed at our department. The surgical treatment outcomes were evaluated retrospectively using a questionnaire, including the postoperative Kujala score. A comprehensive examination was carried out in 42 patients (70%) who had completed the questionnaire. In case of distal realignment, the TT-TG distance and a change in the InsallSalvati index which serve as an indication for surgery, were assessed. RESULTS Altogether 42 patients (70%) and 46 surgical interventions (64%) were evaluated. The follow-up period was 1-11 years, with the mean follow-up of 6.9 years. In the studied group of patients, only 1 case (2%) of new dislocation was seen, in 2 cases (4%) the patients reported a subluxation episode. The mean score using the school grades was 1.76. Thirty-eight patients (90%) were satisfied with the surgical outcome, 39 patients would undergo a surgery in case of identical problems with the other limb. The mean postoperative Kujala score was 76.8 points, range 28-100 points. The mean TT-TG distance in the studied group with the preoperative CT scan (33x) was 15.4 mm (12-30 mm). The mean TT-TG distance in the cases indicated for tibial tubercle transposition was 22.2 mm (15-30 mm). The mean Insall-Salvati index prior to the performance of tibial tubercle ventromedialization was 1.33 (1-1.74). Postoperatively, the index decreased by 0.11 on average (-0.00 to -0.26) to 1.22 (0.92-1.63). No infectious complications were presented in the studied group. DISCUSSION In patients with recurrent patellar dislocation, the instability is often times caused by pathomorphologic anomalies of the patellofemoral joint. In patients with clinically expressed patellar instability and physiological values of the TT-TG distance, an isolated proximal realignment is performed by medial patellofemoral ligament (MPFL) reconstruction. In the case of pathological values of the TT-TG distance, distal realignment is performed by tibial tubercle ventromedialization to achieve physiological values of the TT-TG distance. In the studied group, tibial tubercle ventromedialization helped decrease the Insall-Salvati index by 0.11 points on average. This has a positive side effect on the patella height, thus on increasing its stability in the femoral groove. In patients with both proximal and distal malalignment, a two-stage surgery is performed. In the isolated cases of severe instability or if symptoms of lateral patellar hyperpressure are present, musculus vastus medialis transfer or arthroscopic lateral release are performed as well. CONCLUSIONS When correctly indicated, proximal, distal realignment or their combination can bring very good functional outcomes with a low risk of recurrent dislocation and postoperative complications. The importance of MPFL reconstruction is confirmed by low incidence of recurrent dislocation in the group investigated in this study, namely when compared with studies referred to in this paper, in which the patients underwent patellar stabilisation using the Elmslie-Trillat procedure. Conversely, leaving the bone malalignment untreated during the isolated MPFL reconstruction increases the risk of its failure. Judging from the obtained results, tibial tubercle ventromedialization also has a positive effect on the patella height through its distalization. Provided the stabilisation procedure is correctly indicated and performed, the patients can get back to their normal activities, often even sports activities. Key words: objective patellar instability, patellar stabilisation, MPFL, tibial tubercle transposition.
研究目的 本研究回顾性分析了2010年至2020年期间在我科进行的髌骨稳定手术的结果。旨在提供更全面的评估,比较不同类型的内侧髌股韧带(MPFL)重建,并证实胫骨结节内移对髌骨高度的有益影响。材料与方法 2010年至2020年期间,我科共对60例有客观髌骨不稳定(OPI)的患者进行了72次髌股关节稳定手术。采用问卷调查回顾性评估手术治疗效果,包括术后库贾拉评分。对42例(70%)完成问卷的患者进行了全面检查。对于远端重新排列的情况,评估了作为手术指征的TT-TG距离和Insall-Salvati指数的变化。结果 共评估了42例患者(70%)和46次手术干预(64%)。随访期为1至11年,平均随访6.9年。在研究的患者组中,仅1例(2%)出现新的脱位,2例(4%)患者报告有半脱位发作。采用学校评分的平均得分为1.76。38例患者(90%)对手术结果满意,39例患者在另一肢体出现相同问题时愿意接受手术。术后库贾拉评分平均为76.8分,范围为28至100分。研究组术前CT扫描(33x)时的平均TT-TG距离为15.4 mm(12至30 mm)。胫骨结节移位病例的平均TT-TG距离为22.2 mm(15至30 mm)。胫骨结节内移术前的平均Insall-Salvati指数为1.33(1至1.74)。术后,该指数平均下降0.11(-0.00至-0.26)至1.22(0.92至1.63)。研究组未出现感染并发症。讨论 在复发性髌骨脱位患者中,不稳定通常由髌股关节的病理形态异常引起。对于临床有明显髌骨不稳定且TT-TG距离生理值的患者,通过内侧髌股韧带(MPFL)重建进行单纯近端重新排列。对于TT-TG距离病理值的情况,通过胫骨结节内移进行远端重新排列以达到TT-TG距离的生理值。在研究组中,胫骨结节内移平均使Insall-Salvati指数降低0.11分。这对髌骨高度有积极的副作用,从而增加其在股骨沟中的稳定性。对于近端和远端排列不齐的患者,进行两阶段手术。在严重不稳定的孤立病例或存在髌骨外侧高压症状时,也进行股内侧肌转移或关节镜下外侧松解。结论 当正确选择适应证时,近端、远端重新排列或其联合应用可带来非常好的功能结果,复发性脱位和术后并发症风险低。本研究中调查的组中复发性脱位发生率低证实了MPFL重建的重要性,即与本文引用的研究相比,那些研究中的患者采用Elmslie-Trillat手术进行髌骨稳定。相反,在单纯MPFL重建过程中不治疗骨排列不齐会增加其失败的风险。从获得的结果来看,胫骨结节内移通过其远端化对髌骨高度也有积极影响。只要稳定手术适应证选择正确且操作得当,患者通常甚至可以恢复体育活动等正常活动。关键词:客观髌骨不稳定;髌骨稳定;MPFL;胫骨结节移位